Women's participation on boards of directors: the effects on business growth and profitability
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.7433/s111.2020.10Keywords:
gender; critical mass; token; profitability; growthAbstract
Purpose of the paper: This study investigates the relationship between female presence in the BoD (Board of Directors), business growth and profitability.
Methodology: Our sample includes 309 listed companies located in the north of Italy. The analysis uses two different measures to quantify the effects of female presence: growth and profitability. Independent variables are measured both in terms of the presence (or absence) of women in the BoD and in terms of female percentage in the composition of the BoD.
Findings: The sole presence of women reduces the companies’ growth (i.e. token effect), while in terms of profitability the presence isn’t statistically relevant. The percentage of female composition of the BoD has a positive impact both in terms of growth and profitability, suggesting the interpretation given by the theory of critical mass.
Research limit: The work assesses the contribution of gender diversity on business growth and profitability through variables that measure female presence and gender composition on BoD, but it doesn’t consider underlying mechanisms or other factors characterizing the BoD.
Practical implications: Our findings suggest a greater awareness of gender differences in order to develop decision-making characteristics and processes that are useful in increasing business performance, and more generally in the company life.
Originality of the paper: This study deepens the gender role in a firm, highlighting the link between female presence in BoD, business growth and profitability, by analyzing token effect and critical mass.
References
AALTIO-MARJOSOLA (2001), “Charismatic leadership, manipulation and the complexity of organizational life”, MIT Sloan School of Management.
ADAMS R., FERREIRA D. (2009), “Women in the boardroom and their impact on governance and performance”, Journal of Financial Economics, vol. 94, n. 2, pp. 291-309.
ALDÁS-MANZANO J., MARTINEZ-FUENTES C. (2012), “Women Entrepreneurship and Performance”, Women’s Entrepreneurship and Economic Policies, pp. 89-108. Springer, New York, NY.
ALDRICH H.E. (1989), “Networking among women entrepreneurs”, Women Owned Businesses, New York, pp.103 -132.
AMORE M.D., GAROFALO O. (2016), “Executive Gender, Competitive Pressures, and Corporate Performance”, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, vol. 131, n. 5, pp. 308-327.
ATKINSON S.M., BAIRD S.B., FRYE M.B. (2003), “Do Female Mutual Fund Managers Manage Differently?”, The Journal of Financial Research, vol. 26, n. 1, pp. 1-18.
BILIMORA D. (2000), “Buildings the business case for women corporate directors”, in Women on corporate boards of directors: International challenges and opportunities (pp. 25-40). Dordrecht. The Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Publisher.
BOND R (2005), “Group Size and Conformity”, Group Processes and Intergroup Relations, vol. 8, n. 4, pp. 331-354.
BONN I., YOSHIKAWA T., PHAN P.H. (2004), “Effects of Board Structure on Firm Performance: A Comparison Between Japan and Australia”, Asian Business and Management, vol. 3, n. 1, pp. 105-125.
BRAMMER S., MILLINGTON A., PAVELIN S. (2009), “Corporate Reputation and Women on the Board”, British Journal of Management, vol. 20, n. 1, pp. 17-29.
BURGESS D., BORGIDA E. (1999), “Who women are, who women should be: Descriptive and prescriptive gender stereotyping in sex discrimination!”, Psychology, Public Policy and Law, vol. 5, n. 3, pp. 665-692.
CAMPBELL K., MĺNGUEZ-VERA A. (2008), “Gender diversity in the boardroom and firm financial performance”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 83, n. 3, pp. 435-451.
CARTER D.A., SIMKINS B.J., SIMPSON W.G. (2003), “Corporate governance, board diversity, and firm value”, The Financial Review, vol. 38, n. 1, pp. 33-53.
CARTER S., ROSA P. (1998), “The financing of male- and female-owned businesses”, Entrepreneurship and Regional Development, vol. 10, n. 3, pp. 225-241.
CATALYST C. (2004), The Bottom Line: Connecting Corporate Performance and Gender Diversity, Catalyst Publications
COLEMAN S. (2000), “Access to capital and terms of credit: a comparison of men- and women-owned small businesses”, Journal of Small Business Management, vol. 38, n. 3, pp. 37-52.
COLEMAN S. (2005), “The impact of Human Capital Measures on the performance women - owned small firms”, Journal Bus Entrep, vol. 17, n. 2, pp 39 - 55.
COLEMAN S. (2007), “Gender and educational leadership in England: a comparison of secondary headteachers’ views over time”, Journal School Leadership and Management, vol. 27, n.4, pp. 383-399.
CORMAN J. (2001), “Gender comparisons in strategic decision-making: an entrepreneurial analysis of the entrepreneurial strategy mix”, Journal of Small Business Management, vol. 39, n. 2, pp. 165-173.
DONATI P. (1997), “Uomo e donna in famiglia: Quinto rapporto CISF”, Man and woman in the family: The Fifth CISF’s report on family in Italy, San Paolo Cinisello Balsamo, Italy.
EAGLY A.H., CARLI L.L. (2003a), “The female leadership advantage: An evaluation of the evidence”, Leadership Quarterly, vol. 14, n. 6, pp. 807-834.
EAGLY A.H., CARLI L.L. (2003b), “Finding gender advantage and disadvantage: Systematic research integration is the solution”, Leadership Quarterly, vol. 14, n. 6, pp. 851-859.
ECKEL C.C., GROSSMAN P.J. (2008), “Men, Women and Risk Aversion: Experimental Evidence”, Handbook of Experimental Economics Results, vol. 1, part. 7, pp. 1061-1073.
ERHART N.L., WERBEL J.D., SHRADER B. (2003), “Board Director Diversity and Firm Financial Performance”, Corporate Governance An International Review, vol. 11, n. 2, pp. 102-111.
ERIKSSON-ZETTERQUIST U., STYHRE A. (2008), “Overcoming the glass barriers: reflection and action in the ‘Women to the Top’ programme”, Gender, Work and Organization, vol. 15, n. 2, pp. 133-160.
ERKUT S., KONRAD A.M., KRAMER V. (2008), “Critical Mass: The Impact of Three or More Women on Corporate Boards”, Organizational Dynamics, vol. 37, n. 2, pp.145-164.
FARELL K.A., HERSCH P.L. (2005), “Additions to corporate boards: The effect of gender”, Journal of Corporate Finance, vol. 11, n. 1, pp. 85-106.
FASCI M.A., VALDEZ J. (1998), “A Performance Contrast of Male- and Female-Owned Small Accounting Practices”, Journal of Small Business Management, vol. 36, n. 3, pp. 1-7.
GALBREATH J. (2011), “Are there gender-related influences on corporate sustainability? A study of women on boards of directors”, Journal of Management and Organization, vol. 17, n. 1, pp. 17-38.
GARCIA-MECA E., GARCIA-SANCHEZ I.M., MARTINEZ-FERRERO J. (2015), “Board diversity and its effects on bank performance: An international analysis”, Journal of Banking and Finance, vol. 53, n. 1, pp. 202-214.
GLOBAL ENTREPRENEURSHIP MONITOR (2017), Women’s Entrepreneurship: 2017/2018 Report, GEM
GOODSTEIN J., GUATAM K., BOEKER W. (1994), “The Effect of Board Size and Diversity on Strategic Change”, Strategic Management Journal, vol. 15, n. 3, pp. 241 - 250.
GREVE A., SALAFF J.W. (2003), “Social Networks and Entrepreneurship”, The Norwegian School of Economics and Business Administration and Department of sociology, vol. 28, n. 1, pp. 1-22.
GUEST P.M., (2009), “The Impact of Board Size on Firm Performance: Evidence from the UK”, The European Journal of Finance, vol. 15, n. 4, pp. 385-404.
GUL S., IRSHAD F., ZAMAN K. (2011), “Factors Affecting Bank Profitability in Pakistan”, Romanian Journal of Economic Forecasting, vol. 14, n. 39, pp. 61-87.
HANEL AND ST-PIERRE (2002), “Effects of R&D Spillovers on the Profitability of Firms”, Review of Industrial Organization, vol. 20, n.4, pp. 305-322
HANEL AND ST-PIERRE (2002), “Effects of R&D Spillovers on the Profitability of Firms”, Review of Industrial Organization, vol. 20, n.4, pp. 305-322
HEILMAN M.E. (2001), “Description and prescription: How gender stereotypes prevent women’s ascent up the organizational ladder”, Journal of Social Issues, vol. 57, n. 4, pp. 657-674.
HEMINWAY J.M.L. (2007), “Sex, Trust, and Corporate Boards”, Hastings Women's Law Journal, vol. 18, n. 117, pp. 173-197.
HILLMAN A.J., CANNELLA A.A., (2007), “Organizational predictors of women on corporate boards”, Academy of Management Journal, vol. 50, n. 4, pp. 941-952.
HILLMAN A.J., CANNELLA A.A., HARRIS I.C. (2002), “Women and racial minorities in boardroom: How do directors differ?”, Journal of Management, vol. 28, n. 6, pp. 747-763.
HOWARD E., ALDRICH A. (1989), “Networking Among Women Entrepreneurs”, New York Women Owned Businesses, pp. 103-132, ed. O Hagan, C Rivchun, D Sexton.
HUMPHREYS M.A., MCLUNG H. (1981), “Women entrepreneurs in Oklahoma”, Review of Regional Economics and Business, vol. 6, n. 2, pp. 13-20.
HUSE Et al. COMPLETARE CON NOMI ALTRI AUTORI (2009), “Women and Employee-Elected Board Members, and Their Contributions to Board Control Tasks”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 89, n. 4, pp. 581-597
IBRAHIM N.A., ANGELIDIS J.P. (1994), “Effect of Board Members Gender on Corporate Social Responsiveness Orientation”, Journal of Applied Business Research (JABR), vol. 10, n. 1, pp. 35-40.
JACOBSON S.W., AALTIO I. (2001), “Strong Objectivity and the Use of Q-Methodology in Cross-Cultural”, Contextualizing the Experience of Women Managers and their Scripts of Career, vol. 14, n. 3, pp. 575-599.
JONES AND MAKEPEACE (1996), “Equal Worth, Equal Opportunities: Pay and Promotion in an Internal Labour Market”, Economic Journal, vol. 106, n. 435, pp. 401-09
JUDGE T.A., PICCOLO R.F. (2004), “Transformational and Transactional Leadership: A Meta-Analytic Test of Their Relative Validity”, Journal of Applied Psychology, vol. 89, n. 5, pp. 755-768.
KANADLI, S.B., PINGYING Z. (2017), “Board Diversity's Effects on Network Tasks and Process Innovation: Role of a High-Power Individual”, Academy of Management Proceedings, Vol. 1. Briarcliff Manor, NY 10510: Academy of Management.
KANTER R.M., (1977a, b), “Some Effects of Proportions on Group Life: Skewed Sex Ratios and Responses to Token Women”, American Journal of Sociology, vol. 82, n. 5, pp. 965-990.
KONRAD A.M. (2008), “Critical Mass: The Impact of Three or More Women on Corporate Boards”, Organizational Dynamics, vol. 37, n. 2, pp. 145-164.
LATANÉ B. (1981), “The Psychology of Social Impact”, American Psychologist, vol. 36, n. 4, pp. 343-356.
LOSOCCO K.A., ROBINSON J., HALL R.H., ALLEN J.K. (1991), “Gender and Small Business Success: An Inquiry Into Women's Relative Disadvantage”, Social Forces, vol. 70, n. 1, pp. 65-85.
LUNDEBERG M.A., FOX P.W., PUNĆCOHAŔ J. (1994), “Highly confident but wrong: Gender differences and similarities in confidence judgments”, Journal of Educational Psychology, vol. 86, n. 1, pp. 114-121.
MAASS A., CLARK R.D. (1984), “Hidden Impact of Minorities: Fifteen Years of Minority Influence Research”, Psychological Bulletin, vol. 95, n. 3, pp. 428-450.
MASTERCARD (2018), Mastercard Index of Women Entrepreneurs, Mastercard.
McKINSEY & COMPANY, (2018), Women in the workplace 2018, McKinsey & Company: Lean In.
MILLER T., DEL CARMEN TRIANA M. (2009), “Demographic Diversity in the Boardroom: Mediators of the Board Diversity - Firm Performance Relationship”, Journal of Management Studies, vol. 46, n. 5, pp. 755-786.
NEMETH C.J. (1986), “Differential contributions of majority and minority influence”, Psychological Review, vol. 93, n.1, pp. 23-32.
NEMETH C.J., WACHTLER J. (1983), “Creative problem solving as a result of majority vs minority influence”, European Journal of Social Psychology, vol. 13, n. 1, pp. 45-55.
OECD (2018), Meeting of the OECD Council at Ministerial Level Key issues paper, Paris, pp. 34-36 http://www.oecd.org/mcm-2018/documents/C-MIN-2018-2-EN.pdf )
OHLOTT P.J., RUDERMAN M.N., CYNTHIA D. (1994), “Gender Differences in Managers' Developmental Job Experiences”, The Academy of Management Journal, vol. 37, n. 1, pp. 46-67.
OLSEN W., HEUVELMAN H., GASH V., VANDECASTEELE L (2010b), Policy Related Factors Offsetting Women’s Low Pay in the UK. Research Report Number 2 from the project, “The Gender Pay Gap in The UK 1995- 2007”.
PALMU-JORONEN, A.-L. (2009), “The Nokia-years”, What can be learned from leadership, Jyväskylä. Atena Kustannus Oy.
PAN Y., SPARKS J.R. (2012), “Predictors, consequence, and measurement of ethical judgments: Review and meta-analysis”, Journal of Business Research, vol. 65, n. 1, pp. 84-91.
PASARIBU P. (2017), “Female Directors and Firm Performance: Evidence from UK Listed Firms”, International Journal of Business, vol. 19, n. 2, pp. 145-166.
PEMA E., MEHAY S. (2010), “The role of job assignment and human capital endowments in explaining gender differences in job performance and promotion”, Labour Economics, vol. 17, n. 6, pp. 998-1009.
PFEFFER J. (1972), “Size and Composition of Corporate Boards of Directors: The Organization and Its Environment”, Administrative Science Quarterly, vol. 17, pp. 218-228.
POST C., BYRON K. (2015), “Women on boards and firm financial performance: A meta-analysis”, The Academy of Management Journal, vol. 58, n. 5, pp. 1546-1571.
POWELL T.C., (1993), “The Role of Ethics in Individual Decision-Making”, Canadian Journal of Administrative sciences, vol. 10, n. 3, pp. 269-279.
QUEIRÓ F. (2016), “The effect of manager education on firm growth”, QJ Econ, vol. 118, n. 4, pp. 1169-1208.
RIDING A., SWIFT C. (1990), “Women business owners and terms of credit: Some empirical findings of the Canadian experience”, Journal of Business Venturing, vol. 5, n. 5, pp. 327-340.
ROSE C. (2004), The Composition of Boards and Financial Performance in Danish Listed Firms -Are the Recommendations from the Nørby Report Beneficial for the Shareholders?, WP 2, Institut for Finansiering, Handelshøjskolen i København.
ROSE C. (2007), “Does female board representation influence firm performance? The Danish evidence”, Corporate Governance An International Review, vol. 15, n. 2, pp. 404-413
RYAN M.K., HASLAM S.A. (2007), “The Glass Cliff: Exploring the Dynamics Surrounding the Appointment of Women to Precarious Leadership Positions”, The Academy of Management Review, vol. 32 n. 2, pp. 549-572.
SABATIER M. (2015), “A women’s boom in the boardroom: effects on performance?”, Journal Applied Economics, vol. 47, n. 26, pp. 2717-2727.
SINGH V., VINNICOMBE S. (2001), “Impression Management, Commitment and Gender: Managing Others’ Good Opinions’”, European Management Journal, vol. 19, n. 2, pp. 183-194
TANFORD S., PENROD S. (1984), “Social Influence Model: A formal integration of research on majority and minority influence processes”, Psychological Bulletin, vol. 95, n. 2, pp. 189-225.
TORCHIA M.T., CALABRÓ A. (2011), “Women Directors on Corporate Boards: From Tokenism to Critical Mass”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 102, n. 2, pp. 299-317.
VAFAEI A., AHMED K., MATHER P. (2015), “Board Diversity and Financial Performance in the Top 500 Australian Firms”, Australian Accounting Review, vol. 25, n. 4, pp. 413-427.
VERMOESEN V., DELOOF M., LAVEREN E. (2013). “Long-term debt maturity and financing constraints of SMEs during the global financial crisis”, Small Business Economics, vol. 41, n.2, pp. 433-448.
VILLALONGA B., AMIT R. (2006), “How do family ownership, control and management affect firm value?”, Journal of Financial Economics, vol. 80, n. 2, pp. 385-417
VINCI M. (1999), “Il lavoro femminile nella prospettiva dei gender studies”, Studi di Sociologia, vol. 37, n. 2, pp. 255-270
WALLBOTT H.G., SCHERER K.R. (1991), “Stress specificities: Differential effects of coping style, gender, and type of stressor on autonomic arousal, facial expression, and subjective feeling”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, vol. 61, n. 1, pp. 147-156.
WATSON J. (2002), “Comparing the Performance of Male- and Female-controlled Businesses: Relating Outputs to Inputs”, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, vol. 26, n. 3, pp. 91-100.
WINTER-EBMER AND ZWEIMULLER (1997), “Unequal Assignment and Unequal Promotion in Job Ladders”, Journal of Labor Economics, vol. 15, n. 1, pp. 43-71
WORLD ECONOMIC FORUM (2017), The Global Gender Gap Report 2017, WEM Publications.
ZENOU E., ALLEMAND I., BRULLEBAUT B. (2016). “Gender Diversity on French Boards: Example of a Success from a Hard Law”, Gender Diversity in the Boardroom, pp. 103-124.
