The interplay between privacy failure, recovery and crisis communication management: an integrative review and research agenda
Keywords:privacy; privacy failure; service recovery; service crisis recovery; crisis communication; data breach; integrative literature review
Purpose of the paper: To integrate different research streams related to privacy, service recovery and crisis communication management in order to systematize and summarize the existing knowledge on recovery after a privacy failure. It also aims to develop an agenda for future research.
Methodology: An integrative literature review assesses and synthesizes previous literature, integrating multiple research streams and proposing a new theoretical framework and research agenda. We identify articles of potential interest in three online databases using keywords, and select those relating to privacy and privacy failure, crisis communication management and service recovery after privacy failure across multiple industries.
Findings: Reviewing literature streams on privacy, service recovery and crisis communication management reveals that multiple theories and approaches have been used to focus on this topic. The most widely used are Justice Theory, Attribution Theory and Situational Crisis Communication Theory. The fragmentation of theories and approaches in different research streams reveals the need for a comprehensive overview of the growing complexity of the phenomenon. Key variables explaining how consumers react to service recovery after privacy failure are identified and summarized in a framework.
Research limits: Because the number of publications is rising rapidly, quantitative insights require methodologies such as a systematic literature review or a meta-analysis.
Practical implications: Findings have implications and offer directions for future academic research.
Originality of the paper: This is the first paper that attempts to integrate different research streams in service recovery from privacy failure to develop a theoretical overview on the topic and to attract academic attention on the interplay between privacy failure, recovery and crisis communication management.
AMEEN N., HOSANY S., PAUL J. (2022), “The Personalisation-Privacy Paradox: Consumer Interaction with Smart Technologies and Shopping Mall Loyalty”, Computers in Human Behavior, vol. 126, pp. 1-12.
AVERY E.J., LARISEY R.W., KIM S., HOCKE T. (2010), “A Quantitative Review of Crisis Communication Research in Public Relations from 1991 to 2009”, Public Relations Review, vol. 36, pp. 190-192.
BABIN B., ZHUANG W., BORGES A. (2021), “Managing Service Recovery Experience: Effects of the Forgiveness for Older Consumers”, Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, vol. 58, pp. 1-10.
BANSAL G., ZAHEDI F.M. (2015), “Trust Violation and Repair: The Information Privacy Perspective”, Decision Support Systems, vol. 71, pp. 62-77.
BELANCHE D., CASALO’ L.V. FLAVIAN C., SCHEPERS J. (2020), “Robots or Frontline Employees? Exploring Customers’ Attributions of Responsibility and Stability After Service Failure or Success”, Journal of Service Management, vol. 31, n. 2, pp. 267-289.
BELL C.R., ZEMKE R.E. (1987), “Service Breakdown: The Road to Recovery”, Management Review, vol. 76, n. 10, pp. 32-35.
BROUGH A.R., MARTIN K.D. (2021), “Consumer Privacy During (And After) the Covid-19 Pandemic”, Journal of Public Policy and Marketing, vol. 40, n. 1, pp. 108-110.
BUNDY J., PFARRER M.D. (2015), “A Burden of Responsibility: The Role of Social Approval at the Onset of a Crisis”, Academy of Management Review, vol. 40, n. 3, pp. 345-369.
BUNDY J., PFARRER M.D., SHORT C.E., COOMBS T.W. (2017), “Crises and Crisis Management: Integration, Interpretation, and Research Development”, Journal of Management, vol. 43, n. 6, pp. 1661-1692.
CHAN E.Y., PALMEIRA M. (2021), “Political Ideology Moderates Consumer Response to Brand Crisis Apologies For Data Breaches”, Computers in Human Behavior, vol. 121, 106801.
CHEN H.S., JAI T.M. (C) (2019), “Cyber alarm: Determining the Impacts of Hotel’s Data Breach Messages”, International Journal of Hospitality Management, vol. 82, pp. 326-334.
CHOI B.C., KIM S.S., JIANG Z. (2016), “Influence of Firm’s Recovery Endeavors Upon Privacy Breach on Online Customer Behaviour”, Journal of Management Information Systems, vol. 33, n. 3, pp. 904-933.
CONFENTE I., SICILIANO G.G., GAUDENZI B., EICKHOFF M. (2019), “Effects of Data Breaches from User-Generated Content: A Corporate Reputation Analysis”, European Management Journal, vol. 37, n. 4, pp. 492-504.
COOMBS W.T. (2004), “Impact of Past Crises on Current Crisis Communication: Insights from Situational Crisis Communication Theory”, The Journal of Business Communication, vol. 41, n. 3, pp. 265-289.
COOMBS W.T. (2007), “Protecting Organization Reputations During a Crisis: The Development and Application of Situational Crisis Communication Theory”, Corporate Reputation Review, vol. 10, n. 3, pp. 163-177.
COOMBS W.T. (2015), “The Value of Communication During a Crisis: Insights from Strategic Communication Research”, Business Horizons, vol. 58, n. 2, pp. 141-148.
COOMBS W.T., HOLLADAY S.J. (1996), “Communication and Attributions in a Crisis: An Experimental Study in Crisis Communication”, Journal of Public Relations Research, vol. 8, n.4, pp. 279-295.
COOMBS W.T., HOLLADAY S.J. (2001), “An Extended Examination of the Crisis Situations: A Fusion of the Relational Management and Symbolic Approaches”, Journal of Public Relations Research, vol. 13, n. 4, pp. 321-340.
COOMBS W.T., HOLLADAY S.J. (2002), “Helping Crisis Managers Protect Reputational Assets: Initial Tests of the Situational Crisis Communication Theory”, Management Communication Quarterly, vol. 16, n. 2, pp. 165-186.
COOMBS W.T., HOLLADAY S.J. (2006), “Unpacking the Halo Effect: Reputation and Crisis Management”, Journal of Communication Management, vol. 10, n. 2, pp. 123-137.
COOMBS W.T., HOLLADAY S.J. (2008), “Comparing Apology to Equivalent Crisis Response Strategies: Clarifying Apology’s Role and Value in Crisis Communication”, Public Relations Review, vol. 34, n. 3, pp. 252-257.
DEAN D.H. (2004), “Consumer Reaction to Negative Publicity: Effects of Corporate Reputation, Response, and Responsibility for a Crisis Event”, Journal of Business Communication, vol. 41, pp. 192-211.
del RÍO-LANZA A.B., VÁZQUEZ-CASIELLES R., DÍAZ-MARTÍN A.M. (2009), “Satisfaction with Service Recovery: Perceived Justice and Emotional Responses”, Journal of Business Research, vol. 62, n. 8, pp. 775-781.
DEVLIN E.S. (2006), Crisis Management and Execution, Auerbach Publications, Boca Raton, NY.
ELLIOTT D., HARRIS K., BARON S. (2005), “Crisis Management and Services Marketing”, Journal of Services Marketing, vol. 19, n. 5, pp. 336-345.
FEDIUK T.A., PACE K.M., BOTERO I.C. (2010), “Crisis Response Effectiveness: Methodological Considerations for Advancement in Empirical Investigations into Response Impact”, in ed. By Coombs W.T., Holladay S.J., The Handbook of Crisis Communication, John Wiley & Sons.
FOLKES V.S., KOLETSKY S., GRAHAM J.L. (1987), “A Field Study of Causal Inferences and Consumer Reaction: The View from the Airport”, Journal of Consumer Research, vol. 13 (March), pp. 534-539.
FRANDSEN F., JOHANSEN W. (2010), “Crisis Communication, Complexity, and The Cartoon Affair: A Case Study”, in ed. By Coombs W.T., Holladay S.J., The Handbook of Crisis Communication, John Wiley & Sons.
FRANDSEN F., JOHANSEN W. (2016), Organizational Crisis Communication, Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA.
FRANDSEN F., JOHANSEN W. (2017), “Strategic communication”, in Scott C.R., Lewis L.K. (Eds.), The international encyclopedia of organizational communication, Wiley-Blackwell, Hoboken, NJ.
GERBER N., GERBER P., VOLKAMER M. (2018), “Explaining the Privacy Paradox: A Systematic Review of Literature Investigating Privacy Attitude and Behavior”, Computers and security, vol. 77, pp. 226 - 261.
GINOSAR A., ARIEL Y. (2017), “An Analytical Framework for Online Privacy Research: What is Missing?”, Information and Management, vol. 54, pp. 948-957.
GODIN S. (1999), Permission Marketing: Turning Strangers into Friends and Friends into Customers, Simon and Schuster, New York.
GRÖNROOS C. (1988), “Service Quality: The Six Criteria of Good Perceived Service Quality”, Review of Business, vol. 9, (Winter), pp. 10-13.
GRÖNROOS C. (1994), Management e Marketing dei servizi, Utet, Torino.
GWEBU K.L, WANG J., WANG L. (2018), “The Role of Corporate Reputation and Crisis Response Strategies in Data Breach Management”, Journal of Management Information Systems, vol. 35, n. 2, pp. 683-714.
HAZARIKA B.B., GERLACH J., CUNNINGHAM L. (2018), “The Role of Service Recovery in Online Privacy Violation”, International Journal of E-Business Research, vol. 14, n. 4, pp. 1-27.
HESS R.L. Jr, GANESAN S., KLEIN N.M (2007), “Interactional Service Failures in a Pseudorelationship: The Role of Organizational Attributions”, Journal of Retailing, vol. 83, n. 1, pp. 79-95.
HOGREVE J., BILSTEIN N., MANDL L. (2017), “Unveiling the Recovery Time Zone of Tolerance: When Time Matters in Service Recovery”, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, vol. 45, pp. 866-883.
JANAKIRAMAN R., LIM J.H., RISHIKA R. (2018), “The Effect of a Data Breach Announcement on Customer Behavior: Evidence from a Multichannel Retailer”, Journal of Marketing, vol. 82, n. 2, pp. 85-105.
JUNG N.Y., SEOCK Y.K. (2017), “Effect of Service Recovery on Customers’ Perceived Justice, Satisfaction, and Word-Of-Mouth Intentions on Online Shopping Websites”, Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, vol. 37, pp. 23-30.
KASHMIRI S., NICOL C.D, HSU L. (2017), “Birds of a Feather: Intra-Industry Spillover of the Target Customer Data Breach and the Shielding Role of IT, Marketing, and CSR”, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, vol. 45, pp. 208-228.
KASTANAKIS, M.N., MAGRIZOS S., KAMPOURI K. (2022), Pain (and Pleasure) in Marketing and Consumption: An Integrative Literature Review and Directions for Future Research”, Journal of Business Research, vol. 140, pp. 189-201.
KAU A.K., LOH E.W.Y. (2006), “The Effects of Service Recovery on Consumer Satisfaction: a Comparison Between Complainants and Non‐Complainants”, Journal of Services Marketing, vol. 20, n. 2, pp. 101-111.
KELLEY H.H. (1973), “The Process of Causal Attribution”, American Psychologist, Feb., pp. 107-128.
KIM M.G., WANG C., MATTILA A.S. (2010), “The Relationship between Consumer Complaining Behavior and Service Recovery: An Integrative Review”, International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, vol. 22, n. 7, pp. 975-991.
KRAFFT M., ARDEN C.M., VERHOEF P.C. (2017), “Permission Marketing and Privacy Concerns - Why Do Customers (Not) Grant Permissions?”, Journal of Interactive Marketing, vol. 39, pp. 39-54.
KRAFFT M., KUMAR V., HARMELING C., SINGH S., ZHU T., CHEN J., DUNCAN T., FORTIN W, ROSA E. (2021), “Insight is Power: Understanding the Terms of the Consumer-Firm Data Exchange”, Journal of Retailing, vol. 97, n. 1, pp 133-149.
KRASNOVA H., VELTRI N.F. (2010), “Privacy Calculus on Social Networking Sites: Explorative Evidence from Germany and USA”, 43rd Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, pp. 1-10.
KRISHNAMURTHT S. (2001), “A Comprehensive Analysis of Permission Marketing”, Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, vol. 6, pp 0-0.
KUIPERS S., SCHONHEIT M. (2021), “Data Breaches and Effective Crisis Communication: A Comparative Analysis of Corporate Reputational Crises”, Corporate Reputation Review, Aug, pp. 1-22.
KUMAR V., ZHANG X.A., LUO A. (2014), “Modeling Customer Opt-In and Opt-Out in a Permission-Based Marketing Context”, Journal of Marketing Research, vol. 51, n. 4, pp. 403-419.
KUMAR V., REINARTZ W. (2018), Customer Relationship management, Springer.
LABRECQUE L.I., MARKOS E., SWANI K., PEÑA P. (2021), “When Data Security Goes Wrong: Examining the Impact of Stress, Social Contract Violation, and Data Type on Consumer Coping Responses Following a Data Breach”, Journal of Business Research, vol. 135, pp. 559-571.
LANGE D., WASHBURN N. (2012), “Understanding Attributions of Corporate Social Irresponsibility”, Academy of Management Review, vol. 37, n. 2, pp. 300-326.
LAUFER R.S., WOLFE M. (1977), “Privacy as a Concept and a Social Issue: A Multidimensional Developmental Theory”, Social issue, vol. 33, n. 3, pp. 22-42.
LEMON K.N., VERHOEF P.C. (2016), “Understanding Customer Experience Throughout the Customer Journey”, Journal of Marketing, vol. 80, n. 6, pp. 69-96.
LOBSCHAT L., MUELLER B., EGGERS F., BRANDIMARTE L., DIEFENBACH S., KROSCHKE M., WIRTZ J. (2021), “Corporate Digital Responsibility”, Journal of Business Research, vol. 122, pp. 875-888.
MA L., ZHAN M. (2016), “Effects of Attributed Responsibility and Response Strategies on Organizational Reputation: A Meta-Analysis of Situational Crisis Communication Theory Research”, Journal of Public Relations Research, vol. 28, n. 2, pp. 102-119
MAGNINI V.P., FORD J.B., MARKOWSKI E.P., HONEYCUTT E.D. (2007), “The Service Recovery Paradox: Justifiable Theory or Smoldering Myth?”, Journal of Services Marketing, vol. 21, n. 3, pp. 213-225.
MALHOTRA A., MALHOTRA C.K. (2011), “Evaluating Customer Information Breaches as Service Failures: An Event Study Approach”, Journal of Service Research, vol. 14, n. 1, pp. 44-59.
MANIKA D., PAPAGIANNIDIS S., BOURLAKIS M. (2017), “Understanding the Effects of a Social Media Service Failure Apology: A Comparative Study of Customers vs. Potential Customers”, International Journal of Information Management, vol. 37, n. 3, pp. 214-228.
MARTIN K. (2018), “The Penalty for Privacy Violations: How Privacy Violations Impact Trust Online”, Journal of Business Research, vol. 82, pp. 103-116.
MARTIN K.D., MURPHY P.E. (2017), “The Role of Data Privacy in Marketing”, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, vol. 45, n. 2, pp. 135-155.
McCOLLOUGH M.A., BHARADWAJ S.G. (1992), “The Recovery Paradox: An Examination of Consumer Satisfaction in Relation to Disconfirmation, Service Quality, and Attribution Based Theories”, Allen C.T. (Ed.), Marketing Theory and Applications, American Marketing Association, Chicago.
MICHEL S., BOWEN D.E., JOHNSTON R. (2009), “Why Service Recovery Fails: Tensions Among the Customer, Employee and Process Perspectives”, Journal of Service Management, vol. 20, n. 3, pp. 253-273.
MILLER J.L., CRAIGHEAD C.W., KARWAN K.R. (2000), “Service Recovery: a Framework and Empirical Investigation”, Journal of Operations Management, vol. 18, n. 4, pp. 387-400.
MISHINA Y., BLOCK E. S., MANNOR M.J. (2012), “The Path Dependence of Organizational Reputation: How Social Judgment Influences Assessments of Capability and Character”, Strategic Management Journal, vol. 33, pp. 459-477.
NGUYEN D.T., MCCOLL-KENNEDY J.R. (2003), “Diffusing Customer Anger in Service Recovery: A Conceptual Framework”, Australasian Marketing Journal, vol. 11, n. 2, pp. 46-55.
NISSENBAUM H. (2010), Privacy in context: Technology, policy, and the integrity of social life, Stanford University Press, Palo Alto.
PALMATIER R.W., MARTIN K.D. (2019), The Intelligent Marketer’s Guide to Data Privacy: The Impact of Big Data on Customer Trust, Springer International Publishing.
RASOULIAN S., GRÉGOIRE Y., LEGOUX R., SÉNÉCAL S. (2017), “Service Crisis Recovery and Firm Performance: Insights from Information Breach Announcements”, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, vol. 45, pp. 789-806.
RAUPP J. (2019), “Crisis Communication in the Rhetorical Arena”, Public Relations Review, vol. 45, n. 4, 101768.
REYNDERS P., KUMAR M., FOUND P. (2020), “‘Lean on me’: an integrative literature review on the middle management role in lean”, Total Quality Management and Business Excellence, pp. 1-37.
SCHWARZ A. (2012), “Stakeholder Attributions in Crises: The Effects of Covariation Information and Attributional Inferences on Organizational Reputation”, International Journal of Strategic Communication, vol. 6, n. 2, pp. 174-195.
SCHOEFER K., ENNEW C. (2005), “The Impact of Perceived Justice on Consumers’ Emotional Responses to Service Complaint Experiences”, Journal of Services Marketing, vol. 19, n. 5, pp. 261-270.
SENGUPTA S., RAY D., TRENDEL O., VAN VAERENBERGH Y. (2018), “The Effects of Apologies for Service Failures in the Global Online Retail”, International Journal of Electronic Commerce, vol. 22, n. 3, pp. 419-445.
SINGH J., CRISAFULLI B. (2016), “Managing Online Service Recovery: Procedures, Justice and Customer Satisfaction”, Journal of Service Theory and Practice, vol. 26, n. 6, pp.764-787.
SMITH A.K., BOLTON R.N., WAGNER J. (1999), “A Model of Customer Satisfaction with Service Encounters Involving Failure and Recovery”, Journal of Marketing Research, vol. 36, pp. 356-372.
SMITH D. (2005), “Business (not) as Usual: Crisis Management, Service Recovery and the Vulnerability of Organisations”, Journal of Services Marketing, vol. 19, n. 5, pp. 309-320.
SMITH J.S., KARWAN K.R., MARKLAND R.E. (2009), “An Empirical Examination of The Structural Dimensions of the Service Recovery System”, Decision Sciences, vol. 40, n. 1, pp. 165-186.
SNYDER H. (2019), “Literature Review as a Research Methodology: An Overview and Guidelines”, Journal of Business Research, vol. 104, pp. 333-339.
STONE E.F., GUEUTAL H.G., GARDNER D.G., MCCLURE S. (1983), “A Field Experiment Comparing Information-Privacy Values, Beliefs, and Attitudes Across Several Types of Organizations”, Journal of Applied Psychology, vol. 68, n. 3, pp. 459-468.
STRAUSS A.L. (1978), “A Social World Perspective”, Studies in Symbolic Interaction, vol. 1, pp. 119-128.
TAX S.S., BROWN S.W., CHANDRASHEKARAN M. (1998), “Customer Evaluations of Service Complaint Experiences: Implications for Relationship Marketing”, Journal of Marketing, vol. 62, pp. 60-76.
TADDICKEN M. (2014), “The ‘Privacy Paradox’ in the Social Web: The Impact of Privacy Concerns, Individual Characteristics, and the Perceived Social Relevance on Different Forms of Self-Disclosure”, Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, vol. 19, pp. 248-273.
TORRACO R.J. (2005), “Writing Integrative Literature Reviews: Guidelines and Examples”, Human Resource Development Review, vol. 4, n. 3, pp. 356-367.
VALENTINI S., ORSINGHER C., POLYAKOVA, A. (2020), “Customers’ Emotions in Service Failure and Recovery: a Meta-Analysis”, Marketing Letters, vol. 31, n. 2, pp. 199-216.
Van VAERENBERGH Y., ORSINGHER C. (2016), “Service Recovery: An Integrative Framework and Research Agenda”, The Academy of Management Perspectives, vol. 30, n. 3, pp. 328-346.
Van VAERENBERGH Y., VARGA D., DE KEYSER A., ORSINGHER C. (2019), “The Service Recovery Journey: Conceptualization, Integration, and Directions for Future Research”, Journal of Service Research, vol. 22, n. 2, pp. 103-119.
VIMALKUMAR M., SHARMA S.K., SINGH J.B., DWIVEDI Y.K. (2021), ‘Okay Google, what About My Privacy?’: User’s Privacy Perceptions and Acceptance of Voice Based Digital Assistants”, Computers in Human Behavior, vol. 120, pp. 106763.
WAN L., ZHANG C. (2014), “Responses to Trust Repair After Privacy Breach Incidents”, Journal of Service Science Research, vol. 6, pp. 193-224.
WANG X., WANG X., LIU Z., CHANG W., HOU Y., ZHAO Z. (2022), “Too Generous to Be Fair? Experiments on the Interplay of What, When, and How in Data Breach Recovery of the Hotel Industry”, Tourism Management, vol. 88, p. 104420.
WARREN S., BRANDEIS L. (1890), “The Right to Privacy”, In Schoeman F. (Ed.), Philosophical Dimensions of Privacy (pp. 75-103), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
WEINER B. (1986), Beyond Achievement Motivation: The Generality of Attribution Theory, In: An Attributional Theory of Motivation and Emotion, SSSP Springer Series in Social Psychology, Springer, New York, NY.
WITHERS M.C., CORLEY K.G., HILLMAN A.J. (2012), “Stay or Leave: Director Identities and Voluntary Exit from the Board During Organizational Crisis”, Organization Science, vol. 23, n. 3, pp. 835-850.
WHITTEMORE R., KNAFL K. (2005), “The Integrative Review: Updated Methodology”, Journal of Advanced Nursing, vol. 52, pp. 546-553.
YANG A., TAYLOR M. (2015), “Looking over, Looking out, and Moving Forward: Positioning Public Relations in Theorizing Organizational Network Ecologies”, Communication Theory, vol. 25, n. 1, pp. 91-115.
YANG W., MATTILA A.S. (2012), “The Role of Tie Strength on Consumer Dissatisfaction Response”, International Journal of Hospitality Management, vol. 31, pp. 399-404.
ZEITHAML V.A., BITNER M.J., GREMLER D.D. (2006), Services Marketing: Integrating Customer Focus across the Firm, 4th Edition, McGraw-Hill, New York, NY.