Substance and symbol in ESG-linked executive compensation: evidence from Italian listed companies
Keywords:ESG, ESG indicators;, QCA, Compensation;
Framing of the research. A very recent development in corporate governance studies is about how to integrate environmental, social and governance (ESG) indicators in executive compensation plans. Particularly, the debate is no longer about whether the use of ESG indicators in executive compensation makes sense, but how to do it in the most effective way.
Purpose of the paper. Based on the Neo-Institutional Theory (NIT) and on the substantive vs. merely symbolic inclusion of ESG criteria in executive compensation plans, we describe the spread and frequency (of use) of ESG indicators in CEOs’ compensation plans designed by Italian listed companies, verifying, at the same time, the quantitative diversification of such indicators and the progress made by selected companies in recent years. In addition, our aim is to provide configurations that enable firms to give a higher weight of ESG indicators in their compensation plans.
Methodology. Our sample covers all Italian listed companies in FTSE Mib during the last 5 years (2017-2021). To analyze data and define the specific configurations mentioned above, we employed the Fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis (Fs/QCA).
Results. In an overall context that shows a relevant progress in the adoption of ESG indicators as part of the compensation plan metrics, three configurations emerged, which achieve the highest ESG weights, and which correspond, according to our interpretation, to different levels of substantiality in ESG implementation.
Research limitations. Firstly, we did not consider other conditions that could have helped to identify cases of symbolic adoption. Secondly, we have not delved into the type of ESG indicators that firms adopt.
Managerial implications. Sustainability-oriented investors might look for cues in the bundle of characteristics of the remuneration policy to infer whether it corresponds to a more or less substantial implementation of the ESG activities.
Originality of the paper. To the best of our knowledge, our database is the first longitudinal database of ESG indicators on CEO’s compensation.
ABDELMOTAAL H., ABDEL-KADER M. (2016), “The use of sustainability incentives in executive remuneration contracts: Firm characteristics and impact on the shareholders’ returns”, Journal of Applied Accounting Research. vol. 17 n. 3, pp. 311-330.
ADU D.A., FLYNN A., GREY C. (2022), “Executive compensation and sustainable business practices: The moderating role of sustainability‐based compensation”, Business Strategy and the Environment, vol. 31, n. 3, pp. 698-736
AGUILERA R.V., WILLIAMS C.A., CONLEY J.M., RUPP D.E. (2006), “Corporate governance and social responsibility: A comparative analysis of the UK and the US”, Corporate Governance: an International Review, vol. 14, n. 3, pp. 147-158.
AGUILERA R.V., RUPP D.E., WILLIAMS C.A., GANAPATHI J. (2007). Putting the S back in corporate social responsibility: A multilevel theory of social change in organizations”, Academy of Management Review, vol. 32, n. 3, pp. 836-863.
AL-SHAER H., ZAMAN M. (2019), “CEO compensation and sustainability reporting assurance: Evidence from the UK”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 158, n.1, pp. 233-252.
ALVESSON M., SPICER A. (2019), “Neo-institutional theory and organization studies: a mid-life crisis?”, Organization Studies, vol. 40, n. 2, pp. 199-218
ASHFORTH B.E., GIBBS B.W. (1990), “The double-edge of organizational legitimation”, Organization science, vol. 1, n. 2, pp. 177-194.
BARAIBAR‐DIEZ E., ODRIOZOLA M.D., FERNANDEZ SANCHEZ J.L. (2019), “Sustainable compensation policies and its effect on environmental, social, and governance scores”, Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, vol. 26, n. 6, pp. 1457-1472.
BARNEA A., RUBIN, A. (2010), “Corporate social responsibility as a conflict between shareholders”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 97, n.1, pp.71-86.
BARON D. (2009), “A positive theory of moral management, social pressure and corporate social performance”, Journal of Economics and Management Strategy, vol. 18, pp. 7-43.
BEBCHUK L.A., TALLARITA R. (2021), Will Corporations Deliver Value to All Stakeholders? Vanderbilt Law Review, vol. 75, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3899421 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3899421
BELTRATTI A. (2005), “The complementarity between corporate governance and corporate social responsibility”, The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance-Issues and Practice, vol. 30, n.3, pp. 373-386.
BHIMANI A., SOONAWALLA K. (2005), “From conformance to performance: The corporate responsibilities continuum”, Journal of Accounting and Public Policy, vol. 24, n. 3, pp. 165-174.
BOUTIN-DUFRESNE F., SAVARIA P. (2004), “Corporate social responsibility and financial risk”, The Journal of Investing, vol. 13, n.1, pp. 57-66.
BOXENBAUM E., JONSSON S. (2017), “Isomorphism, diffusion and decoupling: Concept evolution and theoretical challenges”, The Sage Handbook of Organizational Institutionalism, vol. 2, pp. 79-104
BOYD B.K., GOVE S., SOLARINO A.M. (2017), “Methodological rigor of corporate governance studies: A review and recommendations for future studies”, Corporate Governance: An International Review, vol. 25, n 6, pp. 384-396.
BRAMMER S., MILLINGTON A. (2005), “Corporate reputation and philanthropy: An empirical analysis”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 61, n. 1, pp. 29-44
CADBURY A. (1992), The financial aspects of corporate governance (Cadbury Report). London, UK: The Committee on the Financial Aspect of Corporate Governance (The Cadbury Committee) and Gee and Co, Ltd
CALTON J.M., PAYNE S.L. (2003), “Coping with paradox: Multistakeholder learning dialogue as a pluralist sensemaking process for addressing messy problems”, Business and Society, vol. 42, n. 1, pp. 7-42.
CARLISLE Y.M., FAULKNER D.O. (2004), “Corporate social responsibility: a stages framework”, European Business Journal, vol. 16, n. 4, pp. 143-151.
CARROLL A.B. (1994), “Social issues in management research: Experts’ views, analysis and commentary”, Business and Society, vol. 33, pp. 5-29.
CLARKSON M.E. (1995), “A stakeholder framework for analyzing and evaluating corporate social performance”, Academy of Management Review, vol. 20, n. 1, pp. 92-117.
CONYON M., SADLER G. (2010), “Shareholder voting and directors’ remuneration report legislation: Say on pay in the UK”, Corporate Governance: An International Review, vol. 18, n. 4, pp. 296-312.
CORNELL B., DAMODARAN A. (2020), “Valuing ESG: Doing Good or Sounding Good?” NYU Stern School of Business, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3557432 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3557432
CUCARI N. (2018), Lo shareholder engagement negli studi di corporate governance: un’analisi empirica mediante la Qualitative Comparative Analysis, Franco Angeli, Milano.
CUCARI N. (2019a), “Determinants of say on pay vote: a configurational analysis”, International Entrepreneurship and Management Journal, vol. 15, n.3, pp. 837-856.
CUCARI N. (2019b), “Qualitative comparative analysis in corporate governance research: a systematic literature review of applications”, Corporate Governance, vol. 19, n. 4, pp. 717-734.
CULLINAN C.P., MAHONEY L., ROUSH P.B. (2017), “Are CSR activities associated with shareholder voting in director elections and say-on-pay votes?”, Journal of Contemporary Accounting and Economics, vol. 13, n.3, pp. 225-243.
DASGUPTA R. (2021), “Financial performance shortfall, ESG controversies, and ESG performance: Evidence from firms around the world”, Finance Research Letters, pp. 102487.
DE CASTRO G.M., LÓPEZ J.E.N., SÁEZ P.L. (2006), “Business and social reputation: Exploring the concept and main dimensions of corporate reputation”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 63, n. 4, pp. 361-370.
DÍAZ V., IBRUSHI D., ZHAO J. (2021), “Reconsidering systematic factors during the COVID-19 pandemic-The rising importance of ESG”, Finance Research Letters, vol. 38, pp. 101870.
DIMAGGIO P.J., POWELL W.W. (1983), “The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields”, American Sociological Review, vol. ???, n. ???, pp. 147-160.
EDMANS A. (2021), Grow the Pie: How Great Companies Deliver Both Purpose and Profit-Updated and Revised, Cambridge University Press.
EKLUND M.A., STERN H.J. (2021), “How COVID-19 reshapes businesses and executive pay for sustainability”, Corporate Governance and Sustainability Review, vol. 5, n.1, pp. 107-119.
ESPOSITO DE FALCO S., CUCARI N., SORRENTINO E. (2016), “Voting dissent and corporate governance structures: The role of say on pay in a comparative analysis”, Corporate Ownership and Control, vol. 13, n.4-1, pp. 188-197
EUROPEAN COMMISSION. (2011). A renewed EU strategy 2011-14 for corporate social responsibility. Communication From the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions.
FAROOQ O., RUPP D.E., FAROOQ M. (2017), “The multiple pathways through which internal and external corporate social responsibility influence organizational identification and multifoci outcomes: The moderating role of cultural and social orientations”, Academy of Management Journal, vol. 60, n. 3, pp. 954-985.
FILATOTCHEV I., WRIGHT M. (2017), “Methodological issues in governance research: An editor’s perspective”, Corporate Governance: An International Review, vol. 25, n. 6, pp. 454-460.
FISS P.C., MARX A., CAMBRÉ B. (2013), Configurational theory and methods in organizational research: Introduction, Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
FLAMMER C., HONG B., MINOR D. (2019), “Corporate governance and the rise of integrating corporate social responsibility criteria in executive compensation: Effectiveness and implications for firm outcomes”, Strategic Management Journal, vol. 40, n. 7, pp. 1097-1122.
FOMBRUN C.J., GARDBERG N.A., SEVER J.M. (2000), “The Reputation Quotient SM: A multi-stakeholder measure of corporate reputation”, Journal of Brand Management, vol. 7, n.4, pp. 241-255
FREEMAN R.E. (1984), Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach, Pitman, Boston.
FREEMAN R.E., VELAMURI S.R. (2006), “A New Approach to CSR: Company Stakeholder Responsibility”, In Kakabadse A. (Ed.), Corporate Social Responsibility (pp. 9-23). Palgrave Macmillan.
FRIEDE G., BUSCH T., BASSEN A. (2015), “ESG and financial performance: aggregated evidence from more than 2000 empirical studies”, Journal of Sustainable Finance and Investment, vol. 5, n. 4, pp. 210-233.
FRIEDMAN M. (1970), “The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Increase Its Profits”, New York Times Magazine, 13 September 1970, pp. 122-126.
FURNARI S., CRILLY D., MISANGYI V.F., GRECKHAMER T., FISS P.C., AGUILERA R.V. (2021), “Capturing causal complexity: Heuristics for configurational theorizing”, Academy of Management Review, vol. 46, n. 4, pp. 778-799
GANGI F., MELES A., D’ANGELO E., DANIELE L.M. (2019), “Sustainable development and corporate governance in the financial system: Are environmentally friendly banks less risky?”, Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, vol. 26, n. 3, pp. 529-547.
GAO S.S., HERAVI S., XIAO J.Z. (2005), “Determinants of corporate social and environmental reporting in Hong Kong: A research note”, Accounting Forum, vol. 29, pp. 233-242
GARCÍA‐CASTRO R., AGUILERA R.V., ARIÑO M.A. (2013). Bundles of firm corporate governance practices: A fuzzy set analysis. Corporate Governance: An International Review, vol. 21, n. 4, pp. 390-407.
GHOSHAL S. (2005), “Bad management theories are destroying good management practices”, Academy of Management learning and education, vol. 4, n. 1, pp. 75-91.
GILLAN S.L., KOCH A., STARKS L.T. (2021), “Firms and social responsibility: A review of ESG and CSR research in corporate finance”, Journal of Corporate Finance, vol. 66, pp. 101889.
GRAAFLAND J.J., EIJFFINGER S.C., SMIDJOHAN H. (2004), “Benchmarking of corporate social responsibility: Methodological problems and robustness”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 53, n. 1, pp. 137-152
GRECKHAMER T. (2016), “CEO compensation in relation to worker compensation across countries: The configurational impact of country‐level institutions”, Strategic Management Journal, vol. 37, n. 4, pp. 793-815.
GRECKHAMER T., FURNARI S., FISS P.C., AGUILERA R.V. (2018), “Studying configurations with qualitative comparative analysis: Best practices in strategy and organization research”, Strategic Organization, vol. 16, n. 4, pp. 482-495.
GREWAL J., SERAFEIM G., YOON A. (2016), “Shareholder activism on sustainability issues”, Available at SSRN 2805512
HALKOS G.E., PAIZANOS E.A. (2016), “Environmental macroeconomics: economic growth, fiscal spending and environmental quality”, International Review of Environmental and Resource Economics, vol. 9, n. 3-4, pp. 321-362.
HAQUE F. (2017), “The effects of board characteristics and sustainable compensation policy on carbon performance of UK firms”, The British Accounting Review, vol. 49, n. 3, pp. 347-364
HAQUE F., NTIM C.G. (2020), “Executive compensation, sustainable compensation policy, carbon performance and market value”, British Journal of Management, vol. 31, n. 3, pp. 525-546.
HARRIS J.D., FREEMAN R.E. (2008), “The impossibility of the separation thesis: A response to Joakim Sandberg”, Business Ethics Quarterly, vol. 18, n. 4, pp. 541-548.
HARRISON J.S., PHILLIPS R.A., FREEMAN R.E. (2020), “On the 2019 business roundtable “statement on the purpose of a corporation”, Journal of Management, vol. 46, n. 7, pp. 1223-1237.
HENISZ W., KOLLER T., NUTTALL R. (2019). ESG framework. McKinsey. https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/strategy-and-corporatefnance/our-insights/fve-ways-that-esg-creates-value
HAUT COMITÉ DE GOUVERNEMENT D’ENTREPRISE (2020), High Committee for Corporate Governance Report. https://hcge.fr/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/Report_HCGE_-2021_EN.pdf
HO C.K. (2005), “Corporate governance and corporate competitiveness: an international analysis”, Corporate Governance: An International Review, vol. 13, n. 2, pp. 211-253.
HONG B., LI Z., MINOR D. (2016), “Corporate governance and executive compensation for corporate social responsibility”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 136, n. 1, pp. 199-213.
JAMALI D. (2008), “A stakeholder approach to corporate social responsibility: A fresh perspective into theory and practice”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 82, n. 1, pp. 213-231
JENSEN M.C., MECKLING W.H. (1976), “Theory of the firm: Managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structure”, Journal of Financial Economics, vol. 3, n. 4, pp. 305-360
JO H., HARJOTO M. A. (2011), “Corporate governance and firm value: The impact of corporate social responsibility”, Journal of business ethics, vol. 103, n. 3, pp. 351-38
JO H., HARJOTO M.A. (2012), “The causal effect of corporate governance on corporate social responsibility”, Journal of business ethics, vol. 106, n.1, pp. 53-72
KAN A.K.S., ADEGBITE E., EL OMARI S., ABDELLATIF M. (2016), “On the use of qualitative comparative analysis in management”, Journal of Business Research, vol. 69, n. 4, pp. 1458-1463.
KHLIF W., CLARKE T., KAROUI L., KAN K.A.S., INGLEY C. (2019), “Governing complexity to challenge neoliberalism? Embedded firms and the prospects of understanding new realities”, European Management Journal, vol. 37, no. 5, pp. 601-610.
KIM H.R., LEE M., LEE H.T., KIM N.M. (2010), “Corporate social responsibility and employee-company identification”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 95, n. 4, pp. 557-569
KIM Y. (2017), “Consumer responses to the food industry’s proactive and passive environmental CSR, factoring in price as CSR tradeoff”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 140, n. 2, pp. 307-321
KRISHNAMOORTHY R. (2021). Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Investing: Doing Good to Do Well. Open Journal of Social Sciences, vol. 9, n. 7, pp. 189-197.
KUO C.S., YU S.T. (2014), “Remuneration committee, board independence and top executive compensation”, Journal of Risk and Financial Management, vol. 7, n. 2, pp.28-44.
LASHGARI M. (2004), “Corporate governance: Theory and practice”, Journal of American Academy of Business, vol. 5, pp. 46-51
LEE J.W., KIM Y.M., KIM Y.E. (2018), “Antecedents of adopting corporate environmental responsibility and green practices”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 148, n. 2, pp. 397-409.
LOZANO-REINA G., SÁNCHEZ-MARÍN G. (2020), “Say on pay and executive compensation: A systematic review and suggestions for developing the field”, Human Resource Management Review, vol. 30, n. 2, pp. 100683.
MAAS K. (2018), “Do corporate social performance targets in executive compensation contribute to corporate social performance?”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 148, n. 3, pp. 573-585.
MACMILLAN K., MONEY K., DOWNING S., HILLENBRAND C. (2004), “Giving your organization SPIRIT: an overview and call to action for directors on issues of corporate governance, corporate reputation and corporate responsibility”, Journal of General Management, vol. 30, n. 2, pp. 15-42.
MATTEN D., CRANE A. (2005), “Corporate citizenship: Toward an extended theoretical conceptualization”, Academy of Management Review, vol. 30, n.1, pp. 166-179.
MATTHEWS MR. (1993), Socially Responsible Accounting, Chapman and Hall: UK.
MELO T., GARRIDO-MORGADO A. (2012), “Corporate reputation: A combination of social responsibility and industry”, Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, vol. 19, pp. 11-31.
MEYER J.W., ROWAN B. (1977), “Institutionalized organizations: Formal structure as myth and ceremony”, American Journal of Sociology, vol. 83, n. 2, pp. 340-363.
MISANGYI V.F., GRECKHAMER T., FURNARI S., FISS P.C., CRILLY D., AGUILERA R. (2017), “Embracing causal complexity: The emergence of a neo-configurational perspective”, Journal of Management, vol. 43, n. 1, pp. 255-282.
MISHRA S. (2020), “ESG Matters”, Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance. https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2020/01/14/esg-matters/
MURPHY K.J. (1985), “Corporate performance and managerial remuneration: An empirical analysis”, Journal of Accounting and Economics, vol. 7, n. 1-3, pp. 11-42.
PAOLONE F., CUCARI N., WU J., TISCINI R. (2021), “How do ESG pillars impact firms’ marketing performance? A configurational analysis in the pharmaceutical sector”, Journal of Business and Industrial Marketing. forthcoming
PAPPAS I.O., WOODSIDE A.G. (2021), “Fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fs/QCA): Guidelines for research practice in Information Systems and marketing”, International Journal of Information Management, vol. 58, pp. 102310.
PARK S.H., ZHANG Y. (2020), “Cultural entrepreneurship in corporate governance practice diffusion: Framing of “independent directors” by US-listed Chinese companies”, Organization Science, vol. 3, n. 6, pp. 1359-1384
PERROW C. (1970), “Departmental power and perspectives in industrial firms”, Power in organizations, vol. 7, pp. 59-89.
RAGIN C.C. (1987), The comparative method: Moving beyond qualitative and quantitative strategies. Berkeley1987.
RAGIN C.C. (2008), Redesigning social inquiry: Fuzzy sets and beyond. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
RAGIN C.C. (2009), “Qualitative comparative analysis using fuzzy sets”, In Rihoux B., Ragin C.C. (Eds.), Configurational comparative methods: Qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) and related techniques (applied social research methods) (pp. 87-121). Thousand Oaks: Sage.
RAGIN C.C., FISS P.C. (2008), “Net effects analysis versus configurational analysis: An empirical demonstration”, In Ragin C.C. (Ed.), Redesigning social inquiry: Fuzzy sets and beyond (pp. 190-212). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
RUSSO A., PERRINI F. (2010), “Investigating stakeholder theory and social capital: CSR in large firms and SMEs”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 91, n. 2, pp. 207-221.
SCHWAB K. (2019), Why we need the “Davos Manifesto” for a better kind of capitalism, World Economic Forum (Vol. 1).
SEN S., BHATTACHARYA C.B., KORSCHUN D. (2006), “The role of corporate social responsibility in strengthening multiple stakeholder relationships: A field experiment”, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, vol. 34, n. 2, pp. 158-166
STATHOPOULOS K., VOULGARIS G. (2016), “The importance of shareholder activism: The case of say‐on‐pay”, Corporate Governance: An International Review, vol. 24, n. 3, pp. 359-370.
STERN H.J. (2020). “Better executive bonus plans for environmental, social and corporate governance (ESG)”, The Journal of Total Rewards. Retrieved from https://www.worldatwork.org/journal/articles/better-executive-bonus-plans-for-environmental-social-and-corporate-governance-esg https://doi. org/10.2139/ssrn, 3611652.
STULZ R.M. (2022), “The Limits of Financial Globalization”, Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, vol. 34, n. 1, pp. 24-31.
SUDDABY R., SEIDL D., LÊ J.K. (2013), “Strategy-as-practice meets neo-institutional theory”, Strategic Organization, vol. 11, n. 3, pp. 329-344
SUN W., ZHAO C., CHO C.H. (2019), “Institutional transitions and the role of financial performance in CSR reporting”, Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, vol. 26, n. 2, pp. 367-376.
THOMANN E., MAGGETTI M. (2020), “Designing research with qualitative comparative analysis (QCA): Approaches, challenges, and tools”, Sociological Methods and Research, vol. 49, n. 2, pp. 356-386.
TIHANYI L., GRAFFIN S., GEORGE G. (2014), “Rethinking governance in management research”, Academy of Management Journal, vol. 57, n. 6, pp. 1535-1543.
VAN BARNEVELD K., QUINLAN M., KRIESLER P., JUNOR A., BAUM, F., CHOWDHURY, A., RAINNIE A. (2020), “The COVID-19 pandemic: Lessons on building more equal and sustainable societies”, The Economic and Labour Relations Review, vol. 31, n. 2, pp. 133-157.
VAN DEN BERGHE L., LOUCHE C. (2005), “The link between corporate governance and corporate social responsibility in insurance”, The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance-Issues and Practice, vol. 30, n. 3, pp. 425-442.
VAN DER LAAN SMITH J., ADHIKARI A., RASOUL H.T. (2005), “Exploring differences in social disclosures internationally: A stakeholder perspective”, Journal of Accounting and Public Policy, vol. 24, pp. 123-151.
VERRECCHIA R.E. (2001), “Essays on disclosure”, Journal of Accounting and Economics, vol. 32, n. 1-3, pp. 97-180.
YA NI A., VAN WART M., SUINO P. (2018). Corporate Social Responsibility: Doing Well and Doing Good. In Building Business-Government Relations (pp. 175-196). London: Routledge.
ZAJAC E.J., WESTPHAL J.D. (1995), “Accounting for the explanations of CEO compensation: Substance and symbolism”, Administrative Science Quarterly, pp. 283-308.
ZUMENTE I., BISTROVA J. (2021), “ESG importance for long-term shareholder value creation: Literature vs. practice”, Journal of Open Innovation: Technology, Market, and Complexity, vol. 7, n. 2, pp. 127.