Searching for the right operations strategy to manage the repair process across the reverse supply chain
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.7433/s109.2019.02Keywords:
reverse logistics; repairing strategy; case studyAbstract
Purpose of the paper: The paper aims to study the impact of different repair process strategies on a retailer’s product returns management operations by focusing on a make-or-buy analysis for an outsourcing-insourcing decision-making process.
Methodology: An action-based research study on a single case study of an Italian small-sized retailer operating in the online commerce was carried out.
Results: Results shed light on the determination of the repair process strategies implemented by the retailer, the identification of the returns rate and the cost and benefits of each single strategy, and the definition of the best practice to be selected.
Research limitations: The main limitation of this research is the focus on a single case study that provides an insight on a specific industrial sector and on determined products.
Practical implications: This study bridges existing gaps in the literature at both theoretical level, by presenting a further case study on the repair process strategies, and at practical level, by determining a fully focused step-by-step analysis of the managerial decision-making process, while choosing the best practice in a make-or-buy framework.
Originality of the paper: This paper provides a make-or-buy analysis of the outsourcing-insourcing reverse logistics activities concerning an e-commerce retailer struggling with the best operations strategy to manage the repair process across the reverse supply chain.
References
AGRAWAL S., SINGH R.K., MURTAZA Q. (2015), “A literature review and perspectives in reverse logistics”, Resources, Conservation and Recycling, vol. 97, April, pp. 76-92.
AGRAWAL S., SINGH R.K., MURTAZA Q. (2016), “Disposition decisions in reverse logistics: Graph theory and matrix approach”, Journal of Cleaner Production, vol. 137, November, pp. 93-104.
AMINI M.M., RETZLAFF-ROBERTS D., BIENSTOCK C.C. (2005), “Designing a reverse logistics operation for short cycle time repair services”, International Journal of Production Economics, vol. 96, n. 3, pp. 367-380.
BERNON M., CULLEN J., GORST J. (2016), “Online retail returns management: integration within an omni-channel distribution context”, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, vol. 46, n. 6-7, pp. 584-605.
BERNON M., ROSSI S., CULLEN J. (2011), “Retail reverse logistics: A call and grounding framework for research”, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, vol. 41, n. 5, pp. 484-510.
BERNON M., ROSSI S., CULLEN J. (2012), “Retail reverse logistics : a call and grounding framework for research”, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, vol. 41, n. 5, pp. 484-510.
BLUMBERG D.F. (1999), “Strategic examination of reverse logistics & repair service requirements, needs, market size, and opportunities”, Journal of Business Logistics, vol. 20, n. 2, pp. 141-160.
CHENG Y.H., LEE F. (2010), “Outsourcing reverse logistics of high-tech manufacturing firms by using a systematic decision-making approach: TFT-LCD sector in Taiwan”, Industrial Marketing Management, vol. 39, n. 7, pp. 1111-1119.
COUGHLAN P., COGHLAN D. (2002), “Action research for operations management”, International Journal of Operations and Production Management, vol. 22, n. 2, pp. 220-240.
DAPIRAN G.P., KAM B.H. (2017), “Value creation and appropriation in product returns management”, International Journal of Logistics Management, vol. 28, n. 3, pp. 821-840.
DAUGHERTY P.J., BOLUMOLE Y., GRAWE S.J. (2019), “The new age of customer impatience: An agenda for reawakening logistics customer service research”, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, vol. 49, n. 1, pp. 4-32.
DE ARAÚJO A.C., MATSUOKA E.M., UNG J.E., MASSOTE A., SAMPAIO M. (2018), “An exploratory study on the returns management process in an online retailer”, International Journal of Logistics Research and Applications, vol. 21, n. 3, pp. 345-362.
DE BOER L., GAYTAN J., ARROYO P. (2006), “A satisficing model of outsourcing”, Supply Chain Forum: An International Journal, vol. 11, n. 5, pp. 444-455.
DEEPEN J.M., GOLDSBY T.J. KNEMEYER A.M., WALLENBURG C.M. (2008), “Beyond expectations: an examination of logistics outsourcing goal achievement and goal exceedance”, Journal of Business Logistics, vol. 29, n. 2, pp. 75-105.
DOWLATSHAHI S. (2010), “A cost-benefit analysis for the design and implementation of reverse logistics systems : case studies approach”, International Journal of Production Research, vol. 48, n. 5, pp. 1361-1380.
DOWLATSHAHI, S. (2000), “Developing a Theory of Reverse Logistics”, Interfaces, vol. 30, n. 3, pp. 143-155.
ELLRAM L.M. (1996), “The use of the case study method in logistics research”, Journal of Business Logistics, vol. 17, n. 2, pp. 93-138.
ENZ M.G., LAMBERT D.M. (2015), “Measuring the financial benefits of cross-functional integration influences management’s behavior”, Journal of Business Logistics, vol. 36, n. 1, pp. 25-48.
FALLE S., RAUTER R., ENGERT S., BAUMGARTNER R.J. (2016), “Sustainability management with the sustainability balanced scorecard in smes: findings from an Austrian case study”, Sustainability, vol. 8, n. 6, p. 545.
FLEISCHMANN M., BLOEMHOF-RUWAARD J.M., DEKKER R.T, VAN DER LAAN E., VAN NUNEN J.A.E.E., VAN WASSENHOVE L.N. (1997), “Quantitative models for reverse logistics: a review”, European Journal of Operational Research, vol. 103, n. 1, pp. 1-17.
GOVINDANK., PALANIAPPAN M., ZHU Q., KANNAN D. (2012), “Analysis of third party reverse logistics provider using interpretive structural modeling”, International Journal of Production Economics, vol. 140, n. 1, pp. 204-211.
GRIFFISS.E., RAO S., GOLDSBY T.J., NIRANJAN T.T. (2012), “The customer consequences of returns in online retailing: an empirical analysis”, Journal of Operations Management, vol. 30, n. 4, pp. 282-294.
GUARNIERI P., SOBREIRO V.A., NAGANO M.S., MARQUES SERRANO A.L. (2015), “The challenge of selecting and evaluating third-party reverse logistics providers in a multicriteria perspective: a Brazilian case”, Journal of Cleaner Production, vol. 96, n. 1, pp. 209-219.
HJORT K., LANTZ B. (2016), “The impact of returns policies on profitability: a fashion e-commerce case”, Journal of Business Research, vol. 69, n. 11, pp. 4980-4985.
HUANG Y.C., YANG M.L., WONG Y.J. (2016), “Institutional pressures, resources commitment, and returns management”, Supply Chain Management:An International Journal, vol. 21, n. 3, pp. 398-416.
JANAKIRAMAN N., SYRDAL H.A., FRELING R. (2016), “The effect of return policy leniency on consumer purchase and return decisions: a meta-analytic review”, Journal of Retailing, vol. 92, n. 2, pp. 226-235.
KARAKAYALI I., EMIR-FARINAS H., AKCALI E. (2007), “An analysis of decentralized collection and processing of end-of-life products”, Journal of Operations Management, vol. 25, n. 6, pp. 1161-1183.
LAMBERT D.M., ENZ M.G. (2017), “Issues in supply chain management: progress and potential”, Industrial Marketing Management, vol. 62, n. 1, pp. 1-16.
LAU K.H., WANG Y. (2009), “Reverse logistics in the electronic industry of China: a case study”, Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, vol. 14, n. 6, pp. 447-465.
LEE J., MCSHANE H., KOZLOWSKI W. (2002), “Critical issues in establishing a viable supply chain/reverse logistic management program”, International Symposium on Electronics and the Environment, IEEE, pp. 150-156.
LI X., OLORUNNIWO F.O. (2008), “An exploration of reverse logistics practices in three companies”, Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, vol. 13, n. 5, pp. 381-386.
LI Y., YING C., CHIN K., YANG H., XU J. (2018), “Third-party reverse logistics provider selection approach based on hybrid-information MCDM and cumulative prospect theory”, Journal of Cleaner Production, vol. 195, September, pp. 573-584.
LU Q., GOH M., GARG M., DE SOUZA R. (2014), “Remanufacturing in Asia: location choice and outsourcing”, International Journal of Logistics Management, vol. 25, n. 1, pp. 20-34.
MCCARTHY I.P., SILVESTRE B.S., KIETZMANN J.H. (2013), “Understanding outsourcing contexts through information asymmetry and capability fit”, Production Planning and Control, vol. 24, n. 4-5, pp. 277-283.
MEADE L., SARKIS J. (2002), “A conceptual analytic network model for evaluating and selecting third-party reverse logistics providers”, Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, vol. 7, n. 5, pp. 283-295.
MOLLENKOPF D., FRANKEL R., RUSSO I. (2011), “Creating value through returns management: exploring the marketing-operations interface”, Journal of Operations Management, vol. 29, n. 5, pp. 391-403.
MOLLENKOPF D., RABINOVICH E., LASETER T., BOYER K. (2007a), “Managing internet product returns: a focus on effective service operations”, Decision Sciences, vol. 38, n. 2, pp. 215-250.
MOLLENKOPF D., RUSSO I., FRANKEL R. (2007b), “The returns management process in supply chain strategy”, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, vol. 37, n. 7, pp. 568-592.
MOMME J., HVOLBY H. (2002), “An outsourcing framework: action research in the heavy industry sector”, European Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management, vol. 8, n. 4, pp. 185-196.
NÄSLUND D. (2002), “Logistics needs qualitative research-especially action research”, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, vol. 32, n. 5, pp. 321-338.
NÄSLUND D., KALE R., PAULRAJ A. (2010), “Action research in supply chain management-a framework for relevant and rigorous research”, Journal of Business Logistics, vol. 31, n. 2, pp. 331-355.
ORDOOBADI S.M. (2009), “Outsourcing reverse logistics and remanufacturing functions: a conceptual strategic model”, Management Research News, vol. 32, n. 9, pp. 831-845.
PAIOLA M., SACCANI N., PERONA M., GEBAUER H. (2013), “Moving from products to solutions: Strategic approaches for developing capabilities”, European Management Journal, vol. 31, n. 4, pp. 390-409.
PELLATHY D., IN J., MOLLENKOPF D., STANK T. P. (2018), “Middle-range theorizing on logistics customer service”, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, vol. 48, n. 1, pp. 2-18.
RABINOVICH E., KNEMEYER A.M., MAYER C.M. (2007), “Why do Internet commerce firms incorporate logistics service providers in their distribution channels? The role of transaction costs and network strength”, Journal of Operations Management, vol. 25, n. 3, pp. 661-681.
RAO S., LEE K., CONNELLY B., IYENGAR D. (2018), “Return Time leniency in online retail: a signaling theory perspective on buying outcomes”, Decision Sciences, vol. 49, n. 2, pp. 275-305.
ROGERS D.S., LAMBERT D., CROXTON K.L., SEBASTIAN G.D. (2002), “The returns management process”, The International Journal of Logistics Management, vol. 13, n. 2, pp. 1-18.
ROGERS D.S., TIBBEN-LEMBKE R. (2001), “An examination of reverse logistics practices”, Journal of Business Logistics, vol. 22, n. 2, pp. 129-148.
RUSSO I. (2008) La gestione dei resi nelle catene di fornitura, Giuffrè, Milano.
RUSSO I., BORGHESI A. (2008), “Il processo di gestione dei prodotti-ritorni”, Sinergie, n. 77, pp. 163.
RUSSO I., CONFENTE I., GLIGOR D., COBELLI N. (2019), “A roadmap for applying qualitative comparative analysis in supply chain research: The reverse supply chain case”, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, vol. 49, n. 1, pp. 99-120.
SACHAN A., DATTA S. (2005), “Review of supply chain management and logistics”, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, vol. 35, n. 9, pp. 664-705.
SAJJANIT C., ROMPHO N. (2019), “Measuring customer-oriented product returns service performance”, The International Journal of Logistics Management, In Press.
SGARBOSSA F., RUSSO I. (2017), “A proactive model in sustainable food supply chain: insight from a case study”, International Journal of Production Economics, vol. 183, part B, pp. 596-606.
SHAHARUDIN M.R., GOVINDAN K., ZAILANI S., TAN K.C. (2015a), “Managing product returns to achieve supply chain sustainability: an exploratory study and research propositions”, Journal of Cleaner Production, vol. 101, August, pp. 1-15.
SHAHARUDIN M.R., ZAILANI S., TAN K.C. (2015b), “Barriers to product returns and recovery management in a developing country: Investigation using multiple methods”, Journal of Cleaner Production, vol. 96, June, pp. 220-232.
SRIVASTAVA S.K. (2008), “Network design for reverse logistics”, Omega, vol. 36, n. 4, pp. 535-548.
STOCK J., SPEH T., SHEAR H. (2006), “Managing product returns for competitive advantage”, MIT Sloan Management Review, vol. 48, n. 1, pp. 57-62.
STRINGER E.T. (2007), Action research, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA.
THIERRY M., SALOMON M., VAN NUNEN J., VAN WASSENHOVE L. (1995), “Strategic issues in product recovery management”, California Management Review, vol. 37, n. 2, pp. 114-135.
VARADARAJAN R. (2009), “Outsourcing: think more expansively”, Journal of Business Research, vol. 62, n. 11, pp. 1165-1172.
VAZ C.R., GRABOT B., MALDONADO M.U., SELIG P.M. (2013), “Some reasons to implement reverse logistics in companies”, International Journal of Environmental Technology and Management, vol. 16, n. 5-6, pp. 467-479.
WALSH G., ALBRECHT A.K., KUNZ W., HOFACKER C.F. (2016), “Relationship between Online Retailers’ Reputation and Product Returns”, British Journal of Management, vol. 27, n. 1, pp. 3–20.
WANG J.J., CHEN H., ROGERS D.S., ELLRAM L.M., GRAWE S.J. (2017), “A bibliometric analysis of reverse logistics research (1992-2015) and opportunities for future research”, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, vol. 46, n. 8, pp. 666-687.
WANG Y., HAZEN B.T. (2016), “Consumer product knowledge and intention to purchase remanufactured products”, International Journal of Production Economics, vol. 181, part B, pp. 460-469.
XIA Y., ZHANG G.P. (2017), “The impact of product returns and retailer’s service investment on manufacturer’s channel strategies”, Decision Sciences, vol. 48, n. 5, pp. 918-955.
XU X., ZENG S., HE Y. (2017), “The influence of e-services on customer online purchasing behavior toward remanufactured products”, International Journal of Production Economics, vol. 187, May, pp. 113-125.
YIN R.K. (2013), Case study research: design and methods, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA.
Web sites
BENTZ B. (2015), Managing reverse logistics to improve supply chain efficiency and reduce cost, supply chain 24/7, Available online at: https://www.supplychain247.com/article/managing_reverse_logistics_to_improve_supply_chain_efficiency_reduce_costs.
DENNIS S. (2018), The ticking time bomb of e-commerce returns, forbes, Available online at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/stevendennis/2018/02/14/the-ticking-time-bomb-of-e-commerce-returns/.
DRIANSKY A., MADDEN P., WEBB, A. (2016), Retail viewpoint: many happy returns for retailers, alixpartners, Available online at: https://emarketing.alixpartners.com/rs/vm.ashx?ct=24f76b15d3e50aedc1d180add62a961ed4be7bb3d38714dd4 cf371647bf8d90ddd7803
ECOMMERCE NEWS (2016), Online returns in Europe, Available online at: https://ecommercenews.eu/online-returns-in-europe/.
KPMG (2017), The truth about online consumers, Available online at: https://assets.kpmg/content/dam/kpmg/xx/pdf/2017/01/the-truth-about-online-consumers.pdf.
LANGLEY C.J., CAPGEMINI (2018), 2018 third-party logistics study, Available online at: https://mymaritimeblog.files.wordpress.com/2017/10/3pl_2018_study.pdf.
NATIONAL RETAIL FEDERATION (2017), Customer returns in the retail industry, Available online at: https://appriss.com/retail/wp-content/uploads/sites/4/2017/12/2017_consumer-returns-in-the-retail-industry-report.pdf.
NATIONAL RETAIL FEDERATION (2018), Customer returns in the retail industry, Available online at: https://appriss.com/retail/wp-content/uploads/sites/4/2018/12/AR3018_2018-Customer-Returns-in-the-Retail-Industry_Digital.pdf.
RAM A. (2016), ”UK retailers count the cost of returns:, Financial Times, Available online at: https://www.ft.com/content/52d26de8-c0e6-11e5-846f-79b0e3d20eaf.
STATISTA.COM (2015), Return deliveries costs worldwide, Available online at: https://www.statista.com/statistics/753437/return-deliveries-costs-region/.
STOCK J.R. (1998), “Development and Implementation of Reverse Logistics Programs”, Available online at: https://trid.trb.org/view/598914.
