Sustainable corporate governance and human rights: Policies and alleged infringements in the garment industry
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.7433/s130.2026.08Keywords:
Sustainable Corporate Governance, Business and Human Rights, Human Rights Infringements, Human Rights PolicyAbstract
Frame of the research: Despite the growing diffusion of corporate human rights policies, evidence on their effectiveness in preventing infringements remains scarce and mixed, and little is known about how policy quality shapes their impact. This study addresses this gap by disentangling policy adoption from policy quality.
Purpose of the paper: This study investigates whether, and under what conditions, corporate human rights policies, that is, public corporate documents that formally articulate a firm's commitment to respect internationally recognised human rights and specify expectations for employees and business partners, function as effective sustainable corporate governance (SCG) mechanisms.
Methodology: To test our hypotheses, we create a novel longitudinal dataset of 156 fashion companies. First, we examine the effect of policy introduction using a Difference-in-Differences approach. Next, we adopt a two-stage selection model to investigate how policy quality heterogeneity is associated with corporate infringements.
Findings: Contrary to expectations, policy adoption alone is not associated with fewer subsequent human rights infringements. Accounting for policy quality reveals a different pattern. Higher-quality human rights policies, that is, those embedding governance sponsorship, operational guidelines, and credible communication, are associated with fewer infringements.
Research limits: The study relies on Business & Human Rights Resource Centre (BHRRC)-reported incidents, which may be affected by visibility bias. Additionally, it focuses on a single high-risk industry, limiting generalisability.
Practical implications: Results underscore the need for sustained investments in policy development, updating, and integration to ensure SCG is effective. Regulators should define minimum quality criteria to avoid symbolic compliance.
Originality of the paper: The study disentangles policy adoption from policy quality, providing quantitative evidence of their distinct effects. Additionally, it introduces a replicable measure of human rights policy quality for SCG and Business and Human Rights (BHR) research.
References
ABADIE A. (2005), “Semiparametric difference-in-differences estimators”, The Review of Economic Studies, vol. 72, n. 1, pp. 1-19.
AGUILERA R.V., JUDGE W.Q., TERJESEN S.A. (2018), “Corporate governance deviance”, Academy of Management Review, vol. 43, n. 1, pp. 87-109.
AGUILERA R.V., ARAGON-CORREA J.A., MARANO V., TASHMAN P.A. (2021), “The corporate governance of environmental sustainability: a review and proposal for more integrated research”, Journal of Management, vol. 47, n. 6, pp. 1468-1497.
ARKANI S., THEOBALD R. (2005), “Corporate involvement in human rights: Is it any of their business?”, Business Ethics: A European Review, vol. 14, n. 3, pp. 191-205.
AVALLONE F., CAMMAROTA A., D’ARCO M., MARINO V., RESCINITI R. (2025), “Activism across borders: Strategic brand approaches for multinational enterprises in Europe”, Sinergie Italian Journal of Management, vol. 43, n. 2, pp. 121-150.
BUHMANN K. (2016), “Public regulators and CSR: The ‘social licence to operate’ in recent United Nations instruments on business and human rights and the juridification of CSR”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 136, pp. 699-714.
CALLAWAY B., SANT’ANNA P.H. (2021), “Difference-in-differences with multiple time periods”, Journal of Econometrics, vol. 225, n. 2, pp. 200-230.
COLLEVECCHIO F., TEMPERINI V., BARBA-SANCHEZ V., MESEGUER-MARTINEZ A. (2024), “Sustainable Governance: Board Sustainability Experience and the Interplay with Board Age for Firm Sustainability”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 197, pp. 371-389.
CHOWDHURY R. (2017), “The Rana Plaza disaster and the complicit behavior of elite NGOs”, Organization, vol. 24, n. 6, pp. 938-949.
DUPONT V., PIETRZAK D., VERBRUGGE, B. (2024), “A step in the right direction, or more of the same? A systematic review of the impact of human rights due diligence legislation”, Human Rights Review, vol. 25, pp. 1-24.
GAREGNANI G.M., MERLOTTI E.P., RUSSO A. (2015), “Scoring firms’ codes of ethics: An explorative study of quality drivers”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 126, n. 4, pp. 541-557.
GIULIANI E. (2016), “Human rights and corporate social responsibility in developing countries’ industrial clusters”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 133, pp. 39-54.
GIULIANI E., NIERI F., VEZZULLI A. (2023), “Big profits, big harm? Exploring the link between firm performance and human rights abuses”, Business and Society, vol. 62, n. 6, pp. 1248-1299.
GIULIANI E., TUAN A., CANO J. (2021), “Creating shared value meets human rights: A sensemaking perspective in small-scale firms”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 173, pp. 489-505.
GRAAFLAND J., SMID H. (2019), “Decoupling among CSR policies, programs, and impacts: An empirical study”, Business and Society, vol. 58, n. 2, pp. 231-267.
HECKMAN J. (1976), “The common structure of statistical models of truncation, sample selection and limited dependent variables and a simple estimator for such models”, Annals of Economic and Social Measurement, vol. 5, n. 4, pp. 475-492.
ILO (2022) Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work and its Follow-up, pp. 1-15, ISBN 978-92-2-037253-1.
JOHNSON G.A., SHRIVER S.K., GOLDBERG S.G. (2023), “Privacy and market concentration: Intended and unintended consequences of the GDPR”, Management Science, vol. 69, n. 10 pp. 5695-6415.
KAVADIS N., THOMSEN S. (2023), “Sustainable corporate governance: A review of research on long-term corporate ownership and sustainability”, Corporate Governance: An International Review, vol. 31, n. 1, pp. 198-226.
LAUDAL T. (2010), “An attempt to determine the CSR potential of the international clothing business”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 96, pp. 63-77.
MONCIARDINI D., BERNA N. (2021), “The organizational dynamics of compliance with the UK Modern Slavery Act in the food and tobacco sector”, Business and Society, vol. 60, n. 2, pp. 288-340.
MUCHLINSKI P. (2012), “Implementing the new UN corporate human rights framework: Implications for corporate law, governance, and regulation”, Business Ethics Quarterly, vol. 22, n. 1, pp. 145-177.
MURPHY M., VIVES J. (2013), “Perceptions of justice and the Human Rights Protect, Respect, and Remedy framework”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 116, n. 4, pp. 781-797.
NACITI V., CESARONI F., PULEJO L. (2022), “Corporate governance and sustainability: A review of the existing literature”, Journal of Management and Governance, vol. 26, n. 1, pp. 55-74.
NIERI F., ASSENZA E., MORREALE V., STROM S., GIULIANI E. (2025). “Mapping corporate harm to human rights and the environment: the brave database”, Zenodo.
NORDA H.K. (2004), The Global Textile and Clothing Industry Post the Agreement on Textiles and Clothing, WTO Discussion Paper No. 5.
OBARA L.J. (2017), “‘What does this mean?’ How UK companies make sense of human rights”, Business and Human Rights Journal, vol. 2, pp. 249-273.
OLSEN T., REHBEIN K., SNELSON-POWELL A., WESTERMANN-BEHAYLO M. (2022), “Human rights in the oil and gas industry: When are policies and practices enough to prevent abuse?”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 6, n. 1, pp. 1512-1557.
PERRY P., OSBURG V., HUQ F., FALL DIALLO M. (2024), “Fashionable ethics: Exploring ethical perspectives in the production, marketing, and consumption of fashion”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 196, pp. 711-721.
PETERS G.F., ROMI A.M. (2014), “Does the voluntary adoption of corporate governance mechanisms improve environmental risk disclosures? Evidence from greenhouse gas emission accounting”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 125, n. 4, pp. 637-666.
PREUSS L., BROWN D. (2012), “Business policies on human rights: An analysis of their content and prevalence among FTSE 100 firms”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 109, pp. 289-299.
RASCHE A., MORSING M., MOON J. (2017), Corporate social responsibility: Strategy, communication, governance. Cambridge University Press.
ROMITO S., VURRO C., POGUTZ S. (2024), “Joining multi‐stakeholder initiatives to fight climate change: The environmental impact of corporate participation in the Science Based Targets initiative”, Business Strategy and the Environment, vol. 33 n. 4, pp. 2817-2831.
RUBINO M., MASTROROCCO I. (2025), “Exploring the influence of board structure and composition on respect for human rights”, Social Responsibility Journal, vol. 21 n. 2, pp. 301-319.
SCHÄFER N., PETERSEN L., HÖRISCH J. (2024), “The interplay between supply chain transparency and NGO pressure: A quantitative analysis in the fashion industry”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 192, pp. 713-727.
SCHREMPF-STIRLING J., VAN BUREN III H.J. (2024), “The importance of human rights for management and organization studies”, British Journal of Management, vol. 00, pp. 1-14.
SCHREMPF-STIRLING J., VAN BUREN III H.J., WETTSTEIN F. (2022), “Human rights: A promising perspective for business & society”, Business and Society, vol. 61, n. 5, pp. 1282-1321.
SCHREMPF-STIRLING J., WETTSTEIN F. (2017), “Beyond guilty verdicts: Human rights litigation and its impact on corporations’ human rights policies”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 145, pp. 545-562.
SOUNDARARAJAN V., WILHELM M., CRANE A., AGARWAL P., SHETTY H. (2025), “Towards a systemic approach for improving working conditions in global supply chains: An integrative review and research agenda”, Academy of Management Annals, vol 19 n. 1, pp. 230-264.
UNITED NATIONS. (2011). “Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights. Implementing the United Nations “Protect, Respect and Remedy” Framework”
VURRO C., ROMITO S., COSTANZO L.A., GHOBADIAN A., RUSSO A. (2024). “Alliance management capabilities in sustainability‐oriented collaboration: Problematization and new research directions”, International Journal of Management Reviews, vol. 26, n. 1, pp. 8-33.
WOLF J. (2014), “The relationship between sustainable supply chain management, stakeholder pressure and corporate sustainability performance”, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 136, n. 4.
