Meeting Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in museum evaluation systems. The case of the Italian National Museum System (NMS)

  • Mara Cerquetti
  • Marta Maria Montella
Keywords: sustainability; museum management; quality levels; evaluation system; partnership

Abstract

Purpose of the paper: This paper aims to investigate if, how and to what extent the Italian National Museum System (NMS) currently includes sustainability in its evaluation system.

Methodology: After discussing the scientific literature on sustainability in management and museum studies, the research performs a quali-quantitative comparative analysis to verify the degree of inclusion of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) approved by the General Assembly of the United Nations in 2015 in the Uniform Quality Levels for Museums (UQLMs) set up in Italy to implement the NMS.

Findings: The research results show that some sustainability dimensions are more relevant in the Italian museum evaluation system than others, highlighting the importance of relationships with external stakeholders and the local context.

Practical implications: The research identifies possible areas for improvement so that the principles and objectives of sustainability can be incorporated in the NMS. It also provides policymakers and museum managers with suggestions for implementing them.

Research limitation: The research only examines UQLMs. Further investigation should verify the current level of the sustainable approach in museum management by analyzing the best practices and activities of museums participating in the NMS.

Originality of the paper: Adding to the scientific literature on museum sustainability, this paper investigates the relationship between culture and sustainability beyond the triple bottom line approach, by considering sustainability to be an integral component of quality and performance measurement in museums. The research also highlights the need for a more holistic approach involving external stakeholders and integrating other measurement tools.

References

ADAMS E. (2010), Towards sustainability indicators for museums in Australia, Collections Council of Australia Ltd, Adelaide, available at: http://significanceinternational.com.au/Portals/0/Documents/Sustainability_indicators_report_by_Eleanor_Adams_11January2010.pdf.

BARILE S., FULCO I., LOIA F., VITO P. (2019), “Approccio sistemico vitale e aspect based sentiment analysis per il governo del territorio”, Sinergie Italian Journal of Management, vol. 37, n. 1, pp. 171-196.

BARILE S., SAVIANO M. (2018), “Complexity and sustainability in management: insights from a systems perspective”, in Barile S., Pellicano M., Polese F. (edited by), Social dynamics in a systems perspective, Springer, Cham, pp. 39-63.

BROPHY S.S., WYLIE E. (2013), The Green Museum. A Primer on Environmental Practice, Second Edition, Altamira Press, Lanham.

BROWN K. (2019), “Museums and Local Development: An Introduction to Museums, Sustainability and Well-being”, Museum International, vol. 71, n. 3-4, pp. 1-13.

BROWN K., DAVIS P., RAPOSO L., edited by (2019), On Community and Sustainable Museums, EULAC Museums, available at: https://eulacmuseums.net/eulac_museums_docs/EULAC_COMPENDIUM.pdf.

CERQUETTI M. (2017), “From value assessment to public value creation and measurement in the museum sector. Theoretical approaches and critical issues in a changing world”, in Bridging theories, strategies and practices in valuing cultural heritage, eum, Macerata.

CERQUETTI M., NANNI C., VITALE C. (2019), “Managing the landscape as a common good? Evidence from the case of ‘Mutonia’ (Italy)”, Land Use Policy, n. 87, pp. 1-11.

CHITIMA S.S. (2015), “Developing sustainable museums through ‘greening’: A case study of the Zimbabwe Military Museum”, in Mawere M. (edited by), African Museums in the Making. Reflections on the Politics of Material and Public Culture in Zimbabwe, Langaa RPCIG, Bamenda.

CHUNG N., TYAN I., LEE S.J. (2019), “Eco-Innovative Museums and Visitors’ Perceptions of Corporate Social Responsibility”, Sustainability, n. 11, pp. 1-16.

COLGLAZIER E.W. (2018), “The Sustainable Development Goals: Roadmaps to Progress”, Science and Diplomacy, vol. 7, n. 1.

CROSSICK G., KASZYNSKA P. (2016), Understanding the value of arts & culture. The AHRC Cultural Value Project, Arts and Humanities Research Council, Swindon

CUBELES X., BARO F. (2006), Culture and Sustainability, Generalitat de Catalunya, Barcelona.

DI PIETRO L., GUGLIELMETTI MUGION R., RENZI M.F., TONI M. (2014), “An Audience-Centric Approach for Museums Sustainability”, Sustainability, n. 6, pp. 5745-5762.

DUXBURY N., CULLEN C., PASCUAL J. (2012), “Cities, culture and sustainable development”, in Anheier H.K., Isar Y.R. (edited by), Cultures and Globalization: Cities, Cultural Policy and Governance, Sage, London, pp. 73-86.

EDWARDS D. (2007), “Corporate Social Responsibility of Large Urban Museums: the contribution of Volunteer Programs”, Tourism Review International, vol. 11, n. 2, pp. 167-174.

ERRICHIELLO L., MICERA R. (2018), “Leveraging Smart Open Innovation for Achieving Cultural Sustainability: Learning from a New City Museum Project”, Sustainability, n. 10, pp. 1-23.

FRIEDMAN A.J. (2007), “The Great Sustainability Challenge: How Visitor Studies Can Save Cultural Institutions in the 21st Century”, Visitor Studies, vol. 10, n. 1, pp. 3-12.

GILMORE A., RENTSCHLER R. (2002), “Changes in museum management. A custodial or a marketing emphasis?”, Journal of Management Development, vol. 21, n. 10, pp. 745-760.

GOLINELLI G.M., edited by (2015), Cultural Heritage and Value Creation. Towards New Pathways, Springer, Cham.

HALL C.M. (2011), “A typology of governance and its implications for tourism policy analysis”, Journal of Sustainable Tourism, vol. 19, n. 4/5, pp. 437-457.

HARRISON J.S., BOSSE D.A., PHILLIPS R.A. (2010), “Managing for stakeholders, stakeholder utility functions, and competitive advantage”, Strategic Management Journal, vol. 31, n. 1, pp. 58-74.

HEDGES E. (2020), “Actions for the future: determining sustainability efforts in practice in Arizona museums”, Museum management and curatorship, April, pp. 1-22.

ICLEI (1994), Charter of European Cities & Towns Towards Sustainability, Aalborg, Denmark.

ICOM, OECD (2018), Culture and local development: maximizing the impact, Guide for Local Governments, Communities and Museums, https://icom.museum/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/ICOM-OECD-GUIDE_EN_FINAL.pdf.

IUCN/UNEP/WWF (1991), Caring for the Earth. A Strategy for Sustainable Living, Gland, Switzerland.

JANES R., CONATY G., edited by (2005), Looking Reality in the Eye. Museums and Social Responsibility, University of Calgary Press, Calgary.

KATES R.W., CLARK W.C., CORELL R., et al. (2001), “Sustainability science”, Science, vol. 292, n. 5517, pp. 641-642.

LAMBERT S., HENDERSON J. (2011), “The carbon footprint of museum loans: a pilot study at Amgueddfa Cymru - National Museum Wales”, Museum Management and Curatorship, 26, n. 3, pp. 209-235.

LOACH K., ROWLEY J., GRIFFITHS J. (2017), “Cultural sustainability as a strategy for the survival of museums and libraries”, International Journal of Cultural Policy, vol. 23, n. 2, pp- 186-198.

LOGAN R., SUTTER G.C. (2012), “Sustainability and Museum Education: What Future are we educating for?”, International Journal of the Inclusive Museum, vol. 4, n. 3, pp. 11-26.

LOULANSKI T. (2006), “Revising the concept for cultural heritage: the argument for a functional approach”, International Journal of Cultural Property, vol. 13, n. 2, pp. 207-233.

MAZANEC J.A., WOEBER K., ZINS A.H. (2007), “Tourism destination competitiveness: From definition to explanation?”, Journal of Travel Research, vol. 46, n. 1, pp. 86-95.

MCCARTHY K.F., ONDAATJE E.H., ZAKARAS L., BROOKS A. (2004), Gifts of the Muse. Reframing the Debate About the Benefits of the Arts, RAND, Santa Monica.

MENDOZA H.M., SANTANA TALAVERA A. (2017), “Museos y participación en destinos turísticos: dinámicas de sostenibilidad”, RITUR - Revista Iberoamericana de Turismo, vol. 7, n. 3, pp. 137-166.

MERRIMAN N. (2008), “Museum collections and sustainability”, Cultural Trends, vol. 17, n. 1, pp. 3-21.

MONTELLA M. (2009), Valore e valorizzazione del patrimonio culturale storico, Electa-Mondadori, Milano.

MONTELLA M. (2012), “Valore culturale”, in Golinelli G.M. (edited by), Patrimonio culturale e creazione di valore. Verso nuovi percorsi, Cedam, Padova, pp. 3-70.

MONTELLA M., DRAGONI P., edited by (2010), Musei e valorizzazione dei Beni culturali. Atti della Commissione per la definizione dei livelli minimi di qualità delle attività di valorizzazione, Bologna, CLUEB-eum.

MUSE (2018), Bilancio di Sostenibilità 2018, Museo delle Scienze, Trento.

NEWELL J., ROBIN L., WEHNER K., edited by (2016), Curating the Future. Museums, Communities and Climate Change, 1st Edition, Routledge, London.

NOCCA F. (2017), “The role of cultural heritage in sustainable development: Multidimensional indicators as decision-making tool”, Sustainability, vol. 9, n. 10, 1882, pp. 1-28.

ÖZER SARI F., NAZLI M. (2018), “Sustaining Cultural Heritage by Means of Museums in an Ever-Changing World”, Gaziantep University Journal of Social Sciences, vol. 17, n. 1, pp. 1-14.

PENCARELLI T., CERQUETTI M., SPLENDIANI S. (2016), “The sustainable management of museums. An Italian perspective”, Tourism and Hospitality Management, vol. 22, n. 1, pp. 29-46.

PETTI L., TRILLO C., MAKORE B.N. (2020), “Cultural heritage and sustainable development targets: a possible harmonisation? Insights from the European Perspective”, Sustainability, vol. 12, n. 3, 926, pp. 1-24.

PINNA A. (2017), “From minimal to essential levels of museum enhancement: can quality in museums contribute to exercising the right of citizenship?”, in Cerquetti M. (edited by), Bridging theories, strategies and practices in valuing cultural heritage, eum, Macerata, pp. 211-224.

POP I.L., BORZA A. (2014), “Increasing the Sustainability of Museums through International Strategy”, Economia. Seria Management, vol. 17, n. 2, pp. 248-264.

POP I.L., BORZA A. (2015), “Sustainable museums for sustainable development”, Advances in Business-Related Scientific Research Journal, vol. 6, n. 2, pp. 119-131.

POP I.L., BORZA A. (2016a), “Factors Influencing Museum Sustainability and Indicators for Museum Sustainability Measurement”, Sustainability, n. 8, pp. 1-22.

POP I.L., BORZA A. (2016b), “Quality in Museums as a Way to Increase Sustainability”, European Journal of Sustainable Development, vol. 5, n. 3, pp. 217-228

POP I.L., BORZA A., BUIGA A., IGHIAN D., TOADER R. (2019), “Achieving Cultural Sustainability in Museums: A Step Toward Sustainable Development”, Sustainability, n. 11, pp. 1-22.

POP I.L., HAHN R.F., RADULESCU C.M. (2018), “Sustainable Development as a Source of Competitive Advantage: An Empirical Research Study in Museums”, UTMS Journal of Economics, vol. 9, n. 1, pp. 73-83.

PURVIS B., MAO Y., ROBINSON D. (2019), “Three pillars of sustainability: in search of conceptual origins”, Sustainability Science, n. 14, pp. 681-695.

QUATTROCIOCCHI B., FAGGIONI F., MONTELLA M.M. (2012), “Protection, preservation and enhancement, three main aspects of the Italian cultural heritage”, in Morvillo A. (edited by), Advances in Tourism Studies. In memory of Clara Stefania Petrillo, McGraw Hill, Milano, pp. 381-408.

QUATTROCIOCCHI B., MONTELLA M.M. (2013), “L’albergo diffuso: un’innovazione imprenditoriale per lo sviluppo sostenibile del turismo”, in Atti del XXV Convegno annuale di Sinergie “L’innovazione per la competitività delle imprese”, Ancona, 24-25 September, pp. 113-130.

RECUERO VIRTO N., BLASCO LÓPEZ M.F., SAN-MARTÍN S. (2017), “How can European museums reach sustainability?”, Tourism Review, vol. 72, n. 3, pp. 303-318.

RODERS A.P., VAN OERS R. (2011), “Bridging cultural heritage and sustainable development”, Journal of Cultural Heritage Management and Sustainable Development, vol. 1, n. 1, pp. 5-14.

ROTA M. (2019), Musei per la sostenibilità integrata, Editrice Bibliografica, Milano.

RUOZI R., RAPISARDA SASSON C. (2005), Italia per tutti. Ambiente, cultura e turismo per rilanciare l’Italia che vale, Università Bocconi Press, Milano.

RUSSO A., VASTOLA V., VURRO C. (2018), “To be or not to be sustainable? Solving the dilemma during the acquisition process”, Sinergie, vol. 36, n. 106, pp. 127-140.

SANDAHL J. (2019), “The Museum Definition as the Backbone of ICOM”, Museum International, vol. 71, n. 1-2, pp. 1-9.

SAVIANO M., DI NAUTA P., MONTELLA M.M., SCIARELLI F. (2018), “The cultural value of protected areas as models of sustainable development”, Sustainability, vol. 10, n. 5, pp. 1567-1586.

SAZONOVA L. (2014), Cultural Aspects of Sustainable Development: Glimpses of the Ladies’ Market, Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung, Sofia.

SOINI K., DESSEIN J. (2016), “Culture-sustainability relation: Towards a conceptual framework”, Sustainability, vol. 8, n. 2, p. 167-179.

SOLIMA L. (2018), Management per l’impresa culturale, Carocci Editore, Roma.

STUBBS M. (2004), “Heritage-sustainability: developing a methodology for the sustainable appraisal of the historic environment”, Planning Practice and Research, vol. 19, n. 3, pp. 285-305.

STYLIANOU-LAMBERT T., BOUKAS N., CHRISTODOULOU-YERALI M. (2014), “Museums and cultural sustainability: stakeholders, forces, and cultural policies”, International Journal of Cultural Policy, vol. 20, n. 5, pp. 566-587.

SUTTER G.C., SPERLICH T., WORTS D., RIVARD R., TEATHER L. (2016), “Fostering Cultures of Sustainability through Community-Engaged Museums: The History and Re-Emergence of Ecomuseums in Canada and the USA”, Sustainability, n. 8, pp. 1-9.

SUTTON S.W., WYLIE E., ECONOMOPOULOS B., O’BRIEN C., SHAPIRO S., XU S. (2017), “Museums and the Future of a Healthy World: ‘Just, Verdant and Peaceful’”, Curator, vol. 60, n. 2, pp. 151-174.

SWARBROOKE J. (2015), “Built attractions and sustainability”, in Hall C.M., Gossling S., Scott D. (edited by), The Routledge Handbook of Tourism and Sustainability, Routledge, Abingdon, pp. 356-364.

THROSBY C.D. (2005), On the sustainability of cultural capital (Vol. 510), Macquarie University, Department of Economics, Sydney.

UNESCO (2019), Culture 2030 Indicators, https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000371562.

WANG Y.C., CHIOU S.C. (2018), “An Analysis of the Sustainable Development of Environmental Education Provided by Museums”, Sustainability, n. 10, pp. 1-19.

WCED (1987), Report of the World Commission on Environment and Development: Our Common Future.

WICKHAM M., LEHMAN K. (2015), “Communicating sustainability priorities in the museum sector”, Journal of Sustainable Tourism, July, pp. 1-18.

WORTS D. (2016), “Museums: Fostering a culture of ‘flourishing’”, Curator, vol. 59, n. 3, pp. 209-218.

ZUTSHI A., CREED A., PANWAR R., WILLIS L. (2020), “Corporate social responsibility (CSR): Curators’ specific responses from Australian museums and art galleries”, Current Issues in Tourism, pp. 1-17.

Published
2021-04-30